Alle verhalen

In haar veertigerjaren ging detransitie goed — behalve het daten

Man · Gedetransitioneerd35
Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.

Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.

Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.

Samenvatting

Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die voor haar detransitie als transvrouw leefde. Detransitie is voor mij per saldo positief geweest en heeft mijn leven op elk gebied verbeterd, behalve in de liefde, waar daten moeilijker is gebleken dan verwacht, zeker nu ik in de veertig ben. De lichamelijke terugdraaiing duurde een paar jaar, waarbij borstgroei de belangrijkste onomkeerbare verandering was. Ik blogde over detransitie maar trok me terug omdat de politisering me uitputte en ik het zat was door beide kanten als politieke speelbal gebruikt te worden. Ik steun nog steeds trans rechten en de autonomie van volwassenen, maar sta ook kritisch tegenover blind bevestigende zorg, en ik wil betere wetenschap om goede kandidaten voor transitie te kunnen onderscheiden.

Volledig verhaal

I detransitioned from living as a trans woman, and while the process took a couple of years for most of the physical changes to reverse, breast growth was the exception that did not fully change back. I found that I needed to lose weight and work out to help the process along. In retrospect I see that it wasn't necessarily being trans itself that felt inauthentic, but rather the constant effort of using my voice in constrained ways and holding my body in constrained ways in order to pass — that was ultimately draining and exhausting. Passing was so important to me at the time and it wasn't completely in my control, which added to those feelings of strain. It feels great now to be able to move freely and fully use my voice, especially singing, which I couldn't really do in a female voice at all when I was transitioned and trying to speak en femme. I'm just now starting to learn to sing. I think my detransition has been a net positive — it improved my life in every sphere except romance. Dating surprised me: I seemed to have an easier time with dating when I was presenting as a trans woman, and I thought it would get easier after detransitioning. Some of that effect may just be aging and being in my 40s. For a long time I didn't try to date at all after detransition because it just felt too impossible. In retrospect I see that avoiding dating was a mistake, and I think it's important to accept that sometimes people will accept it and sometimes they won't, just like any other facet of being a person. Like any other difficult topic, it's not necessarily something to disclose immediately, but it's also a barrier to intimacy, so you have to feel into when the right time is to disclose. It can work — I did eventually find a relationship, though we since broke up. One woman did reject me for that reason, but even she was willing to consider it. I really think it's the psychological barriers that get in the way more than the fact that you detransitioned. It is not impossible, but it is difficult, no question. I took a break for a while from blogging about detransition to deal with the rest of my life. The politicization of this issue is exhausting and it was one of the reasons I took that break. I did not appreciate being used as a political football. Right-wing and radfem groups would attempt to use detransition in order to discredit trans people in general, and trans activists and social justice people would sometimes just make stuff up in order to discredit or minimize detransition. I took the stance that I was open to talking to anyone and got repeatedly accused of being aligned with radfems and the religious right just because I would talk to them. I want there to be good science around detransition, better ways to differentiate who is a good candidate for gender transition, and a fuller knowledge of ways to deal with dysphoria. I support trans rights fully, think transition is appropriate for some people and does help them (this is supported by research), think adults have the right to do what they want with their bodies, and also that there are a lot of problems with blindly affirming people, as we are currently witnessing with the growth in the number of detransitioners. I wish there was a way that trans people and detransitioners could work together on this, because it seems like it is in both groups' interest to prevent regret and find more ways to work with dysphoria, but it is very difficult with all of the politicization going on. I'm aware of research efforts in this area, including a general detransitionerrer study with a primary investigator I follow that hasn't been published yet, and a follow-up effort focused on the youth population that includes both desisters and detransitioners.