Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die is gedesisteerd nadat een trans-activistengroep op mijn universiteit me onder druk zette om een operatie te ondergaan die ik niet wilde. Ik heb nooit hormonen genomen of een operatie gehad; ik pakte ernstige genderdysforie aan met sport, therapie, meditatie en herinterpretatie, en nu identificeer ik me als een vrouw die gewoon niet past in genderstereotypen. Ik was depressief tot halverwege mijn twintigers en maakte bijna-doodtrauma en een bendegerelateerde LSD-aanval mee, maar mijn leven verbeterde sterk nadat ik mijn omgeving en gewoonten veranderde. Nu werk ik in de tech, heb een dochter en een partner, en pleit ik tegen medische transitie voor minderjarigen en tegen therapie die alleen bevestigt, terwijl ik een genderonconforme presentatie wel steun. Ik heb geen spijt dat ik niet ben getransitioneerd en prijs me gelukkig dat de cultuur destijds nog niet zo voor operaties was.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female and I have always been female. I never connected with the idea of womanhood — my whole life people told me I behave like a man, and my interactions with women only differed from my interactions with men when the men were predatory or sexist. In high school I was an extreme athlete, around 80 lbs, and I didn't develop breasts then. When I hit college I stopped exercising and my boobs and ass 'came out of no where' — I ran down a set of stairs and for the first time it hurt, and looking in the mirror I didn't feel like that person; my body felt foreign and wrong. I had strong dysphoria at that point. If there had been an easy option to cut them off I would have, 100%.
In college I was in a trans activist/discussion group at an all women's college surrounded by other colleges — we campaigned for gender neutral bathrooms and ran education campaigns about violence against women including violence against trans women. I also frequented the local drag club with the group and had a LOT of fun in drag: I loved going to drag clubs and dressing in drag for college parties, but I also loved wearing mini skirts to my everyday classes, especially with unshaven legs and having guys do a double take. I loved the juxtaposition of femininity and masculinity and didn't want to be tied to one. I had been presenting as male for some time.
The turning point came in a group meeting where people discussed how hard it was to get surgery. I said waiting was reasonable because of the lifelong consequences of the procedures, and that medical transition was not the only option — that acting and dressing like a traditional male didn't mean I had to change my body. The pushback was hard; others were adamant that surgery was the only way for trans people to feel normal. It came across that people were trying to make everyone think the same way to reaffirm their own beliefs. I left the group, re-examined what I wanted out of life, and decided presenting as male wasn't the way to get there. I desisted. I never used hormones or had surgery — being pushed toward surgical transition is what caused me to stop transitioning.
I later worked out a personal mental strategy for the dysphoria: when I looked in the mirror and felt wrong, I would go with it and compliment my body as if I were a man who had ended up in a woman's body — 'if I were male, I wouldn't be upset or depressed to be in a woman's body... I'd be fucking stoked. Because... boobs.' I would grab my boobs and think how lucky I was. Eventually things melded and I stopped feeling my body was wrong. I also used yoga, meditation, and a lot of exercise. I say plainly: 'Ultimately I'm not trans.' I'm a person who didn't fit into a gender stereotype and had severe gender dysphoria that was fixable by exercise, therapy, and understanding that gendered behavior is a societal performance. I still, most 20 years later, feel like my mind and behavior don't fit the mold society presents for my gender, but now I know society can go f itself and I can be however I want in my body.
I was depressed and unhappy until I was around 26-27. More than 10 years ago my life was 'an absolute nightmare' — I spent every night crying, didn't leave my house for months, and used any method I could to escape. I had a close call and realized my happiness was within my power to change; I left a toxic friend group and sought out people taking charge of their own happiness, which completely changed my life. I also experienced physical and psychological trauma resulting in near death, and complete betrayal and rejection of my entire friend group as a reaction to my pain and trauma. I was personally a victim of gang hazing/rape rituals in Southern California involving LSD — I was drugged, and it took me years to reconcile what happened; I can type the details but saying them out loud brings a massive panic in my chest. I've also observed young men in those groups who were less aggressive being sexually abused, and in one case a man there said he thought he was trans after an 'outing.' I have also been bullied — once chased to a car by a group screaming I should kill myself.
Family: I'm the only one in my family with a college degree and a solid career; I've worked in tech for over 20 years. My younger brother, who hasn't held a job for more than a month and lived with our parents until his 30s, gets more respect than me — 'No matter what I did, it was better to be male then me.' My dad acted as someone who cut off discussion: you disagreed with him and you were an idiot. I associate aggression and shutting down discussion with that patriarchal behavior.
I have a daughter; I spent the first three months of her life crying in the shower from exhaustion and grief. I make more than my partner. My partner is comfortable wearing skirts and has let me put makeup on him; we have extensive friends in the kink community and I have a very fluid sexuality. I dated women for several years, then the first guy I ever dated I met when he was wearing a skirt, a drummer in the Rocky Horror picture show — I realized I wasn't unattracted to men, just to men stuck and limited by the image of themselves. I've dated many lesbians. I met my current partner when I had a mostly shaved head, no makeup, heavy leather boots, and was doing performative martial arts.
I did opera training in my youth. I get migraines (light/sound sensitivity, auras, no pain). I had a friend who ghostwrote for — actually I ghost wrote a book for a woman who had a breast cancer mastectomy with gruesome aftercare, which framed my view of such surgery as serious damage. I have a five-year-old nephew who likes pink nail polish and robots.
On the community side, I posted about r/TwoXChromosomes because I was frustrated at extreme censorship — I got insta-banned there for trying to discuss why people feel uncomfortable with anyone being able to use women's bathrooms, and the mods were rude when I tried to clear it up. I want r/detrans to remain a safe space where difficult topics are open to discussion. I've watched Contrapoints and pro-transition subreddits to make sure my language is gentle; I asked the community for a better word than 'mutilation' because I'm not neurotypical and often blunt. I shared a Buck Angel interview ('You Are Here') recommending it. I advocate strongly against medical transition for children ('children can't consent'), against affirmation-only therapy, and against irreversible medical changes unless someone is 100% certain. I've said affirmation-only is cult behavior. I don't hate trans people; I've never met a feminist who hates trans people. My core advice to others: don't do anything you can't undo unless it's coming from you alone; exercise, meditation, nutrition, and therapy before drastic changes; presentation and clothing are costumes and don't require altering your body.