Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde/gedesisteerde vrouw die in mijn late tienerjaren als trans identificeerde nadat ik tot de conclusie kwam dat ik een mannenziel/-brein had, maar ik geloof niet meer in genderidentiteit en beschrijf mijn resterende gevoelens nu als AAP (autoandrofilie) plus autismegerelateerd ongemak met vrouwelijke sociale omgang. Ik ben nooit medisch getransitioneerd — ik fantaseer nog over testosteron maar praat mezelf eruit vanwege de gezondheidsrisico's, en ik zie transitie als zinloos omdat het me geen functionele penis kan geven. Mijn genderproblemen zijn nu 'beheersbare achtergrondruis', en ik heb een prettige, onconventionele relatie met een mannelijke partner die weet dat ik AAP ben. Ik ben een actieve criticus van online trans- en 'egg'-cultuur geworden, omdat die mensen die vatbaar zijn voor fixatie schaadt, en ik pleit dat identiteit geconstrueerd en evoluerend is in plaats van aangeboren. Ik ervaar nog steeds afgunst op mannen en ongemak met de vrouwelijke rol in seks, maar ik heb me erbij neergelegd te leven zoals ik ben zonder medische ingreep.
Volledig verhaal
I was born female. I didn't care about gender as a kid — being a girl was just a physical fact to me, like my hair colour, and I had both masculine and feminine interests. I was disinterested in socialising for most of my childhood, but when I did play with other kids I preferred playing with boys. Around age 10 the girls stopped wanting to play and just walked around the playground talking, and I didn't get what they were talking about or why it was interesting, so I played football with the boys instead. Around 16 I became more interested in making friends — my social development lagged way behind my peers — and I gravitated towards nerdy male friend groups because their interests aligned with mine. I wasn't really 'one of the boys' but we got along. Hearing from other girls and women made me realise I had hardly any typical female experiences.
I was mostly apathetic about puberty; I developed relatively late, slowly, and with no drastic changes (at 16 strangers thought I was 12). The one memory of discomfort was my mum making excited remarks about me 'shaping up', which confused and annoyed me. I think my dysphoric feelings coincided with developing a sexuality — I didn't have concrete sexual thoughts until 16 or 17. I experience some same-sex attraction, but my attraction to males is much stronger because I feel kinship with them and am envious of them. Pretty much every guy I've found attractive has been someone I perceived as a better version of myself. In sexual fantasies I imagine myself as male (though after discovering futa porn I sometimes imagine myself as a futa). Many fantasies involve male institutions, especially the military. I was never a fujoshi and find yaoi offputting.
I found out about the concept of gender identity in my teens and concluded I had a male soul/brain, instead of just being an eccentric girl as I'd previously thought. I became frustrated with my sex characteristics and wished for narrower hips, a flat chest, a leaner muscular physique, sharper facial features, and most of all a penis. I no longer believe in gender identity — after thinking about it, it ceased to make logical sense — but the frustration hasn't gone away. I still fantasise about taking testosterone and getting lean, though I talk myself out of it because of the risks to my health and hair. I also see transition as pointless for me because it's not a true sex change and there's no way for me to grow a functional dick.
I have little sexual experience because I don't like the female role in sex. Part of my envy of males is that they get to choose between penetrating and being penetrated, they have a prostate, their anatomy seems more straightforward and reliable, and there's no risk of pregnancy. As a teen I believed I wasn't attractive to others and might be celibate for life, but I felt neutral and resigned rather than distressed — I'm solitary and have never seen being alone as bad, and I didn't want irl sex because of hygiene/STD/pregnancy fears and hating the idea of being penetrated. I found very few people I met irl attractive and was more interested in fictional characters, so I was happy to stick to fantasy. I thought I was asexual when younger, but I definitely don't have low libido — it just took until my late teens for my sex drive to become aimed at real-life people.
After finding out about the female version of AGP, I thought AAP (autoandrophilia) might explain a lot about me. I now describe myself as AAP. My fantasies often involve hierarchical and ritualistic situations, discipline and dominance (but not outright violence), and focus on penetration as a dominant act. I once read Susan Sontag's essay 'Fascinating Fascism' about the psychosexual appeal of fascism and it resonated with me. I fit most criteria of 'anal retentiveness' and am competitive and overly concerned about my own inferiority/superiority. I experience tension between reasoned anti-authoritarian principles and a base desire for control.
I have autism. I've noticed that when talking to female friends I'm anxious and tense and not sure what to say, while with male friends conversation is 'easy mode'. I've noted that autism and being 'male-brained' are similar, and that female autists find female social groups difficult because communication is indirect and high-context — I speak from personal experience. I don't socialise a lot: I have one close male friend known since school, I'm in a male-dominated undergrad course with a few acquaintances, I've drifted from most of my school friend circle (some of whom have since transitioned MtF), and I have a sister who's a friend. I don't consider myself lonely; I'm naturally introverted and solitary.
I have a male partner — the only relationship I've been in. We're both bisexual and probably autistic, don't have a typical gender dynamic, are open with each other, and he's aware I'm AAP and sympathises with me. It's a comfortable relationship.
Currently my sex/gender issues are more like manageable background noise that becomes more prominent when I'm in a negative mental state. I feel no obligation to make myself conventionally attractive as a female because I care more about liking what I see in the mirror than being found attractive by others. I don't want to be seen in a sexual light unless I actively choose to.
I've become a vocal critic of online trans communities. I posted a long analysis of how 'egg' culture and gender-questioning rhetoric is psychologically damaging, especially to people prone to fixations like those with OCD or autism. I described how mantras like 'if you think you are trans then you are' and 'cis people don't question their gender' create Kafka traps and rumination spirals, and how the community's Pascal's-wager framing makes every questioning process lead to transition. I've observed social groups where one person's 'egg cracks' and others follow, and I think this is because neurodivergent and mentally ill people form groups together and 'cracked eggs' become 'crackers' through confirmation bias — a kind of psychological pyramid scheme. I've also written about how the internet contributes to trans identification through echo chambers, online persona over physical existence, and the stress of staying 'in character' on social media. I no longer believe in gender identity as an inborn immutable core; I think identity is constructed and can evolve. I don't believe cis people exist as the trans community defines them, or that people are 'destined trans' — the only thing that makes someone trans is undertaking transition. I'm critical of both sides of the culture war and think conservatives are ignorant about the plight of gender dysphoric or GNC people. I support bodily autonomy and don't think being on HRT is wrong, but I question the worldview behind the desire and warn against banking on it to fix one's life.