Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een gedetransitioneerde vrouw die een borstoperatie had en testosteron nam, en ik zette oestrogeen niet door deels omdat ik betwijfelde of ik ooit als vrouw zou kunnen doorgaan. Ik heb geen leeftijden, data of details gegeven over wanneer ik voor het eerst dysforie voelde, transitioneerde of detransitioneerde. Ik betoog nu dat testosteron je gezondheid verwoest en dat vrouw zijn is wat iemand een vrouw maakt, ongeacht uiterlijk. Mijn bijdragen hier zijn voornamelijk korte, vaak vijandige wisselingen met andere detransitioners, onder meer een thread waarin ik de stem en platte borst van een andere detrans-vrouw beledigde. Ik heb niets gezegd over therapie, geestelijke gezondheid, familie, relaties of mijn huidige levenskwaliteit.
Volledig verhaal
I have posted mostly short, combative comments rather than a full account of my own history, but a few things about me come through. I am female by birth, and I have lived through both sides of medical transition: I was on testosterone long enough that other people now tell me I have "a man voice," and I have had top surgery — at one point stating flatly that I have no breasts, and later clarifying that I have silicone, i.e. reconstructed breasts. I have also been on estrogen, or at least seriously evaluated going on it, since I refer to "estrogen" as something I know the limits of from experience.
On 2023-10-19 I got into a long argument with another detransitioned woman on this board. I had checked her profile out of curiosity after she made a comment I disliked — she had, in my view, shitted on "a fellow detrans woman for her presentation." I told her she was "a piece of shit," that she had "no tits and a man voice," and that if she thought other people should stay out of women's spaces, the same rule should apply to her. When she pointed out I had claimed top surgery myself, I argued that both claims can't be true at once and that either she was lying then or lying now. When she said her breasts were implants, I shot back: "lol so you dont have breasts, you have silicone. MTFs can get that too, doesnt make them women." I also defended the original poster of that thread, insisting she was "female therefore a woman no matter what she looks like," and asked the other woman "do you not know what butch means or something?" Underneath the hostility, my consistent position in that exchange was that being female is what makes someone a woman, appearance notwithstanding, and that the other commenter was "projecting your own insecurities."
Earlier, on 2023-01-09, I wrote a genuinely cruel reply to someone, telling them they didn't have "internalized transphobia" but were "just a shitty person," that people like them never change, and that unless they were honest with themselves they would be "a miserable self hating female for the rest of your life." I also called them "a delusional female" and said they were projecting their insecurities onto their ex — "You're literally the same lmao." That comment scored 21 upvotes.
My tone has not always been hostile. On 2023-03-27 I defended a poster who was being downvoted for asking about reversing the effects of testosterone, arguing that "when someone decides to transition its because they want the effects of hrt" and that people can change their minds, comparing a condescending reply to telling someone asking about laser hair removal "didn't you know you would grow a beard?" I explained I was responding simply because "im bored as hell during down time at work and you asked."
On 2023-12-20 I commented, "so you agree, testosterone ruins your health?" — suggesting I now view testosterone as damaging. On 2024-02-10 I mocked a man for complaining about misandry, writing "misandry is when people call me out for being a creep" and telling him to "go spend time with your family instead of hitting on girls young enough to be your daughter." In that same thread I gave my clearest statement about my own medical path: "keep in mind that estrogen doesnt actually change much for men, its extremely unlikely you will pass as female ever. thats one big reason i never went through with it." That implies I seriously considered feminising hormones after detransition but chose not to proceed, partly because I doubted I could ever be read as female.
I have not described my age, when I first felt dysphoria, when I came out, when I started or stopped testosterone, when I had top surgery, or how I detransitioned. I have not mentioned therapy, diagnoses, trauma, family, partners, sexuality, or how I feel day to day now. What is visible is that I am a detransitioned woman who has had top surgery and masculinising hormone treatment, who did not go through with estrogen, who defends other detransitioned women's right to be female regardless of how masculine they look, and who argues aggressively and often cruelly when I think someone is being unfair.