Deze verhalen zijn samengevat met behulp van AI.
Op Reddit delen mensen vaak hun ervaringen in meerdere reacties of posts. Om deze informatie toegankelijker te maken, verzamelt detrans.ai al die verspreide stukjes in één, gemakkelijk te lezen samenvatting en tijdlijn. Alle systeemprompts zijn genoteerd op de prompts-pagina.
Soms kan AI hallucineren of dingen stellen die niet waar zijn. Maar over het algemeen zijn de samengevatte verhalen nauwkeurige weergaven van de originele reacties van gebruikers.
Samenvatting
Ik ben een detransitionerende of twijfelende vrouwelijke persoon die zich als FTM identificeerde en enkele jaren als man leefde op testosteron, en ik voel nu dat mijn geslacht vrouwelijk is en dat gender voor mij geen nuttig of betekenisvol concept is. Mijn kernpijn is levenslange invalidatie en vernedering van mijn identiteit als vrouw met masculiene eigenschappen, voortkomend uit pesten vanwege genderonconformiteit en geïnternaliseerde misogynie en homofobie. Ik wou dat mijn eerste therapeut en voorschrijvende arts mijn geschiedenis en gevoelens nieuwsgieriger hadden onderzocht zonder kaders op te leggen. Filosofie, met name Zizek over de inconsistentie van seksuele identiteit, en zelfbedachte schrijfoefeningen hebben me geholpen mijn emotionele behoeften los te weven van gender. Ik vind sommige veranderingen door testosteron nog steeds fijn, maar weet niet hoe ik waarheidsgetrouw kan leven in alle dimensies van mezelf, en ik zoek een gemeenschap die vrouwelijke masculiniteit viert zonder anti-trans te zijn.
Volledig verhaal
I am a female person who identified as trans and lived as male for several years, and I have been on testosterone for several years. I now identify as female again and describe myself as FTM and questioning. My core, abiding pain is lifelong, persistent invalidation, invisibility, and humiliation of my identity as female, specifically having physical traits, behavior tendencies, and ways of being that are perceived as masculine. I was bullied for gender non-conformity as a female person. I feel that strong emotions have become linked to gender and my biological sex, and I am working hard to stop ruminating about gender identity and to untie a 'big knot' inside me.
I wish that the first therapist I saw, or the doctor who provided the hormones, had asked me more about my history of gender dysphoria - how long I had these feelings and what was going on in my life when they started. I wish they had been more curious and attuned, checking in about how the care felt for me, in a way that was validating, non-intrusive, and left it up to me while still allowing me to be the expert on myself. I think I may have been irritated or hurt by such questioning at the time, but if it were asked openly without coercion or imposition in any direction, I might have been able to accept myself more easily in what I was experiencing around internalized misogyny, homophobia, and challenges from presenting as gender non-conforming.
I have found philosophy helpful in digging my way out of ideas that were unhelpful to me. I shared detailed notes on Slavoj Zizek's views on gender identity, including ideas like 'I don't trust this passion for categorization,' that 'every social identification comes with a doubt,' that 'sexual identity is always at core inconsistent,' and that subjectivity is the plus itself (LGBT+) - not a new category but excess over identity. These resonated with me because they validate uncertainty and complexity rather than demanding fixed categories.
I created writing exercises for myself to help dis-entangle my emotional needs from gender or biological sex. I also wish I had allowed myself truly free space - a locked diary or secret document - to pour out all my 'not allowed' feelings and thoughts, particularly those I was actively suppressing because they felt embarrassing, shameful, scary, or wrong. In the end all of that contained useful information about myself, and I felt sad I had spent so much energy pushing it away.
I feel starved for conversations where I can be accepted as female without being in spaces that are antagonistic or highly politically motivated against trans people, where I fear being criticized or attacked given my own experiences. I most fear being 'resented and rejected for having a complex experience.' I use Reddit as a diary at times and find something beautiful about being able to say full truths privately and have others hear it. I celebrate butchness and female masculinity passionately - I feel strong excitement, camaraderie, attraction, and joy when I see female people who break the rules of femininity, and I find little celebration of this way of being. I also relate to other women who describe losing deep connections with women after transitioning, saying 'something about womanhood, seeing women interact with each other, remembering what it was like when I was a woman interacting with women, all of that, just feels innately connected to me.'