Все истории

Никогда не переходила — дисфория отступила благодаря любви к своему телу

Женщина · Отказался(ась)1,2 тыс.
Эти истории были суммированы с использованием ИИ.

На Reddit люди часто делятся своим опытом в нескольких комментариях или постах. Чтобы сделать эту информацию более доступной, detrans.ai собирает все эти разрозненные части в одно легко читаемое резюме и хронологию. Все системные промпты указаны на странице промптов.

Иногда ИИ может галлюцинировать или утверждать то, что не соответствует действительности. Но в целом суммированные истории являются точным отражением оригинальных комментариев пользователей.

Резюме

Я союзник, близкий к detrans: женщина, не соответствующая гендерным нормам, аутичная (аспи), изучающая биологию, которая сама боролась с гендерной дисфорией, но никогда не совершала переход, и обрела покой, приняв гендерное несоответствие и поддержку матери любить своё тело. Я пережила период депрессии в начале 2020 года, отчасти вызванный моим баном в r/science за ссылку на r/detrans, и описываю прежний травматический опыт, из-за которого стала параноидально думать, что другие меня ненавидят. У меня нет истории гормонов или операций. Теперь я громкий критик медицинского перехода и гендерно-подтверждающей помощи, сравниваю переход с липосакцией при анорексии и с конверсионной терапией, и выступаю за терапию без гендерного подтверждения, отмену гендера и защиту детей от медикализации. Сейчас я идентифицирую себя как женщина, которая просто ещё одно животное женского пола, и активно участвую в сообществах detrans и радикальных феминисток как союзник.

Полная история

I was born female and I have never transitioned — I am a gender-nonconforming woman who has struggled with gender dysphoria myself and who came to the r/detrans community as an ally. I am on the autism spectrum (I call myself an Aspie, and I say my realization of that came very late in life), and I am graduating in biology, currently in my second year of biology studies at university, which is my favourite subject. My own gender discomfort is something I describe openly. I write that I always slouched because of my breasts and was paranoid they attracted too much attention, and that I have recurrent acne and psoriasis, weird skin I compare to alligator hide, a weak jaw, orange-toned legs, and floppy breasts. I also mention partial face blindness — my brain does not process faces accurately — which I say helps me stop comparing people. I say I have always liked being around boys more than girls and prefer men's clothes for comfort and utility. I have many times dreamed I had a penis. I also say I have struggled with gender dysphoria myself, but that this should not qualify or disqualify me from the conversation. What saved me, I say, was my mother. She asked me several times if I was trans 'under it all,' and I remember thinking, 'Mom goddammit just because im a bit masculine doesnt mean im a boi.' She always encouraged me to see the beauty in my body, to cherish even the flaws, and taught me that being a woman does not dictate how you should act — it is just an indicative idea of what your body looks like and functions (vagina, boobs of any shape and size, periods and the like). She even bought into the 'wrong body' thing for a moment once and asked if I really wanted to be a man. I do not blame her — 'parents are just kids having kids' — but I wonder whether, if she had asked earlier, I might have started second-guessing my sex. I say plainly: 'That is what happens when you gaslight children.' I also say I would have been convinced by society that I was a boy in a girl's body if my mom hadn't encouraged me to dress how I liked. The turning point for me was embracing gender nonconformity. I write: 'as soon as i embraced gender non conformity, it felt like a curtain was lifted. No more i had to be described by gender, fluidity or not, but just a whim, will i wear pants or a sarong today?' I describe the day I realized this as the best day ever — 'not like with fanfare or fireworks, but like sitting down on a pier at sundown, finally stopping to look at the stars... Finally, a peace that tastes like a new beginning.' I say my mind could never really wrap around the 'weird gender thing,' and that this saved me 'so much pain and anguish.' I describe myself as 'just another female animal, that happens to be of the homo sapiens sapiens species.' I also describe a parallel realization about autism: I was always worried I wasn't getting invisible clues, always paranoid that people around me were there out of pity and secretly hated me (I call this a 'traumatic experience from the past, otherwise it would have never crossed my mind'). Then I realized that if they hate me and don't say so, that's on them — so I now tell people to their face, 'always be direct with me, i dont get clues, i wont get offended.' I say I never lie anymore, especially about what I like or who I am. I also describe a mirror technique I developed: because the subconscious sees the reflection as another person, I treat that person in the mirror as someone in my care — 'Take care of yourself like you would your little brother' — and I say this outlook changed my life. I say I retrain my subconscious with conscious effort, driving good vibes into it. I also say I don't look at many images of other bodies, so I only have my own to contemplate and don't compare. I wear clothes from both sides of the aisle, am quite tomboyish, and say it took time to love my body as I do now. I tried losing weight but didn't like my face too thin. I say I was never convinced I was male because I never believed in the individuality of brain/body — a view I say was reinforced by studying biology ('we ARE our body'). I cut my own hair and describe it as freeing self-reliance. I use honey topically for acne, psoriasis, and a second-degree burn on my face that left no scar. On the community side, I posted twice. In one post I shared a 4thWaveNow article, 'Gender Dysphoria Is Not One Thing,' calling it 'informative, complete and honest.' In another post I described being banned from r/science for commenting 'r/detrans to see why this shouldnt be a thing,' and I wrote that I was in tears, that I have Asperger's and am 'not that good at knowing when something is socially unacceptable,' that a lot of my self-confidence is based on the scientific community, and that I had no one to turn to. I said the ban 'froze me' and killed my will to study cytology and histology for the day, which I had been neglecting during a depression streak. My views are strongly critical of medical transition. I repeatedly compare gender dysphoria to anorexia and surgery to liposuction, call transition 'a confirmation of gender stereotypes,' say dysphoria is a symptom of something deeper and cannot itself be cured, and argue that transition is 'basically conversion therapy' given its historical overlap with chemical castration and genital removal used against gay people in the 1950s. I say the trans movement follows the BITE model for cults 'every point,' compare it to the repressed-false-memory movement, and say it uses what happened to gay people to foster a cult mentality. I am critical of gender-affirming therapists ('avoid those like a plague'), recommend non-gender-affirming therapy repeatedly, and advocate stopping 'the pipelining of children to doctors instead of children to psychologists.' I say puberty blockers hinder brain development and that the brain isn't finished until about 25. I say I don't believe trans people should be denied existence outright — 'i do believe trans people exist, im not sure surgery works tho' — and that SRS should be a huge minority reserved for people who have been for years to psychologists. I say I have no horse in this race and am 'a bit of a nihilist.' I share studies critical of transition outcomes (including regret-after-SRS papers and Lisa Littman's work), critique meta-analyses for not following up long-term or including desisters, and note that no study has focused on desisters. I say my professors and colleagues in the field worry the political climate is rushing studies past standard peer review, and that there is a 'reproduction crisis' in science. I say I am a transhumanist (unrelated to transsexuals) and would be fine with an 'Altered Carbon' sleeve-swap scenario, but that transition is often a bad coping mechanism. I say I am against sexism from all sides, was banned from r/gendercritical for defending a man against misandry, and describe myself as allergic to conflict. I advocate gender abolition and gender nonconformity as 'the way forward,' and I encourage detransitioners to tell their stories, consider suing doctors, and organize to raise awareness. I also say I am gay or at least bi-adjacent in the sense of being outside heteronormativity — actually, I do not state my own orientation directly; I only comment on others'. I am against spirituality ('we need community, not wishful thinking') and describe myself as a nihilist/atheist-adjacent. I say English is not my first language and I live in Europe. I have no stated history of hormones, blockers, or surgeries. My ongoing medical needs are topical (honey for acne/psoriasis) and I mention a depression streak in early 2020.