Watson: Dolgoročne študije ne kažejo, da medicinska obravnava spola preprečuje samomor (članek je umaknila revija za medicinske sestre)

Kakšna so dejstva o transspolnih mladostnikih in samomoru? Ponoven pogled na pripoved o samomorih transspolnih mladostnikov

Authors
Jason Watson
Journal
Australian Nursing and Midwifery Journal
Year
2026

Summary

In this short article for an Australian nursing magazine, New Zealand mental health nurse Jason Watson challenges the idea that withholding gender-affirming treatment from young people drives them to suicide. He looks at six large, long-term studies from the Netherlands, Sweden, Denmark, the UK and Finland. In his reading, suicide rates among transgender people stayed well above the general population after treatment, rates fell over time only for trans women in one Dutch study, and the Tavistock clinic review found no rise in youth suicides after access to puberty blockers was restricted in England. He concludes that the 'transition or suicide' claim is weak at best. The article was printed in July 2026, then removed from the journal's website after complaints; the nurses' union apologised for publishing it but later said this did not imply misconduct by the author. It is an opinion piece, not a systematic review: it picks a handful of studies, most of them about adults, and some of its readings go further than the studies' own authors. For example, the Finnish study it relies on most concluded that suicide risk was explained by mental illness and that gender reassignment did not change suicide risk either way.

Key findings

  • Watson dvomi v pogosto ponavljano trditev, da so mladi, ki jim je spolno potrjujoča obravnava odrečena, bolj izpostavljeni samomoru; to trditev so podali WPATH in ameriški zdravstveni uradniki.
  • Pregleda šest dolgoročnih nadaljnjih študij z Nizozemske, Švedske, Danske, Združenega kraljestva in Finske, ki zajemajo od 324 do več kot 15.000 ljudi in obdobja spremljanja od 5 do 46 let.
  • Poroča, da so stopnje samomorov in smrti med transspolnimi osebami tudi po obravnavi ostale višje kot v splošni populaciji ter da je le ena nizozemska študija pokazala upadanje samomorov skozi čas, in sicer pri transspolnih ženskah.
  • Izpostavi pregled samomorov v angleški kliniki Tavistock, ki je ugotovil 12 samomorov in nobenega porasta samomorov med mladimi po omejitvi zaviralcev pubertete, kljub napovedim o strmem porastu.
  • Zaključi, da je pripoved »prehod ali samomor« »vsaj šibka, v najslabšem primeru pa preprosto napačna«, kar se sklada z ugotovitvijo Cassovega poročila, da je večina raziskav na tem področju slabe kakovosti.
  • Avstralski sindikat medicinskih sester je članek julija 2026 umaknil s spletne strani svoje revije in se opravičil za objavo, pozneje pa pojasnil, da to ni pomenilo ugotovitve o neprimernem ravnanju avtorja.

Abstract

This short article examines the narrative that trans youth who are not provided with gender-affirming healthcare face an increased risk of suicide, a view stated by WPATH's Standards of Care 8 and the US Assistant Secretary for Health in 2022. Noting the Cass Review's finding that research in this field is of poor quality, the author summarises six long-term follow-up studies from the Netherlands (Wiepjes 2020; de Blok 2021), Sweden (Dhejne 2011), Denmark (Erlangsen 2023), England (Appleby 2024, a review of suicides among Tavistock gender clinic patients) and Finland (Ruuska 2024), with sample sizes from 324 to 15,032 and follow-up from five to 46 years, and describes what each reported about suicide and mortality.

Conclusion

Only one finding, the decline in suicide among trans women over time in Wiepjes (2020), appeared to support the narrative that lack of access to gender-affirming care increases suicide risk. The author argues the other studies showed no evidence that treatment reduced suicidal behaviour, and reported higher 'other' mortality after treatment, and that Ruuska (2024), the only study with a matched control group, found much higher suicide and overall mortality among trans people. He concludes the 'trans suicide narrative' is 'at least tenuous and at most simply incorrect', consistent with the Cass Review's view that most research in this field is of poor quality.