Ці історії були узагальнені за допомогою ШІ.
На Reddit люди часто діляться своїм досвідом у кількох коментарях або постах. Щоб зробити цю інформацію більш доступною, detrans.ai збирає всі ці розрізнені частини в одне легке для читання узагальнення та хронологію. Усі системні промпти зазначені на сторінці промптів.
Іноді ШІ може галюцинувати або стверджувати речі, які не є правдою. Але загалом узагальнені історії є точним відображенням оригінальних коментарів користувачів.
Резюме
Я народився чоловіком і ніколи не переходив медично — мені відмовили в гормональній терапії після того, як я попросив тестостерон, бо я вважав себе «дефектним чоловіком» із соціальними та сексуальними проблемами. Ці проблеми значною мірою розв'язалися пізніше в житті, коли я зміг мати регулярні сексуальні стосунки. Тепер я ідентифікую себе як desist/детранс-чоловік, який гостро критикує гендерну ідеологію, яку я порівнюю з релігією, і особливо медичний перехід для молоді. Я зазнав кар'єрних наслідків через свої політичні погляди, що змусило мене тимчасово видалити свої погляди з інтернету. Тепер я відкрито говорю онлайн, попереджаю інших і розраджую тих, хто сумнівається в гендерній ідеології або розчарований нею.
Повна історія
I was born male and, looking back, I never had a clear sense of what being trans actually meant — I just knew I had social problems and couldn't get sex partners. At one point I was actively trying to get more testosterone because I thought I was "a faulty male." I was denied any hormonal care in the end, so I never went through a full medical transition, but the mindset was there. I now realize that guys struggling to find sexual partners is probably true for the majority of males, and that my hangups were not evidence that I was a different sex.
Later in life I actually managed to get sex quite consistently with lots of sexual partners, and my hangups started to go away on their own. That experience is a big part of why I now worry about much more vulnerable boys — the transmaxxxers and similar communities — when nobody dares speak out about how common these struggles are. I also spent time following PUA guys, which I now see as toxic, and I appreciate Jordan Peterson as a healthier counterweight to the common leftist attitude toward men, which I feel is either "you are a disgusting incel if you can't get laid" or "men have it so easy."
I think the culture around gender has gone haywire. I mostly download old movies and series now because some of the new ones are almost unbearable — I point to the latest Sandman as having maybe 10% straight people and all of them in terrible relationships. I believe people need to be robust enough not to start freaking out about their identity every time media shifts. I compare "genderism" to a religion — agreeing with Nina Paley on the Heterodorx podcast — and liken the medical transition of children to witch-hunts, communist struggle sessions, and child sacrifice, as well as to genital circumcision in other religious sects. I note how early some systems allow medical interventions: "one year after becoming a legal adult, before you are even allowed to drink alcohol in some countries."
I have given advice to others cautioning against detransitioning for the sake of a partner, warning that a straight partner will likely want a biological woman eventually, and that one shouldn't make life-altering decisions on the whims of a partner. I've also reassured people worried about their looks that very few people are grown really hot looking, and that even if genitalia are removed there is always something interesting left in life to pursue. I've told someone leaving a partner sucked into what I call "a crazy cult" that they are not neglecting their partner's identity — they are leaving to keep themselves sane, comparing it to people quietly going along with the Chinese Cultural Revolution or North Korea while privately knowing the ruling elite's statements don't make sense.
I remember my first rejection due to political ideology when I was younger: everyone was happy to see me, the recruiters were stoked, the interview guy liked me, then I got a message that they couldn't hire me. I talked with the background-check guy, who confirmed I was too controversial. After that I scrubbed my name from the net, removed political statements, and often had to beg people to remove comments from old blogs — sometimes pretending I believed things I didn't. I now write publicly about how easy it is to get fired or even denied bank services for the wrong opinion, and I try to reassure people questioning gender ideology that there are tons of people who don't think they're toxic for not believing in "genderism" or the woke anymore.
Current status: I am a detransitioned/desisted male who never received hormones after being denied care, and I now hold critical views of transition, especially for young people, and speak about it openly.