Усі історії

Чоловіче ім'я та «він», а потім повернення до дівчини

Жінка · Відмовився(лась)631
Ці історії були узагальнені за допомогою ШІ.

На Reddit люди часто діляться своїм досвідом у кількох коментарях або постах. Щоб зробити цю інформацію більш доступною, detrans.ai збирає всі ці розрізнені частини в одне легке для читання узагальнення та хронологію. Усі системні промпти зазначені на сторінці промптів.

Іноді ШІ може галюцинувати або стверджувати речі, які не є правдою. Але загалом узагальнені історії є точним відображенням оригінальних коментарів користувачів.

Резюме

Я жінка, яка здійснила зворотний перехід, яка пройшла соціальний перехід і ідентифікувала себе як гендерфлюїд, перш ніж вирішила повернутися до життя дівчини. Я ніколи не робила медичного переходу, хоча експериментувала з чоловічим іменем і займенниками he/him. Тепер я виступаю за те, щоб дівчата приймали себе як жінок, і критикую медичний перехід, лікарів, які на ньому заробляють, і соціальну заразність, яка, на мою думку, штовхає багатьох дівчат-підлітків до ідентифікації як ftm. Я стикалася з сексуальним насильством з боку батька і нав'язливими прив'язаностями, які покращилися, коли я перестала їх плекати. Я продовжую активно підтримувати інших у зворотному переході.

Повна історія

I was born female. Looking back, I showed 'signs' from about 8 to 11 years old — I tried to go by the name 'Bob' and called myself a boy at around 9, plus the usual tomboy things, but I never knew the word 'trans' and my parents, though definitely weirded out, basically ignored it and never took me to a 'gender therapist' or tried to socially transition me. I'm very lucky in that regard. I never really started to consciously experience gender dysphoria or try to transition, and I never had a moment of 'realizing I'm not trans' since I never thought of it that way. I go to a pretty liberal school in a red state. I never medically transitioned, but I did socially experiment — at one point I identified as genderfluid and asked people to use he/him and a different name, which I later stopped. I eventually decided to socially detransition and embrace being a girl again. I don't wear makeup or dresses, most of my friends are boys, but I'm otherwise very normal for a girl my age. The social side of detransitioning was the hardest part — having to tell everyone to stop using he/him and the new name. I decided to just present more as a girl and let people catch on rather than announcing it everywhere. I told myself you don't lose friends through detransitioning, you just discover who your real friends are. I'm still androgynous-looking; people have told me my voice sounds female but that if I looked more feminine no one would bat an eye. I've thought a lot about what leads girls like me here. I was always a tomboy, and I noticed so many teen girls my age identifying as ftm — an absurd jump in numbers that I believe is a social fad, damaging though it may be. I've read about the study showing suicidality is highest 10 years after medical intervention, and I'm skeptical of studies showing 'positive effects' of transitioning kids since they're made by people who profit off the treatment — like Marlboro funding lung cancer research. I researched bottom surgeries and found it the most gruesome thing I've ever done. I've dealt with my own intrusive thoughts and fixations. When I was looking into certain distressing material, the more I did it the more it fed a cycle of thinking about it constantly. When I took a break and just started acting normal, it went away. I used to give advice to ignore and not dwell on such thoughts — comparing it to eating disorders, where you can't get better until you stop constantly thinking about your weight. I've also dealt with things swelling up emotionally at times. I've been sexually affected by family trauma: my father sexually abused me, and I've had to worry about him even after getting away. CPS frustrated me — going after parents who don't 'support' their trans kids while turning a blind eye to actual abuse. I also had a trans friend (ftm) with a rough upbringing — sexually groomed by a much older male friend, three stepfathers, at least one abusive — and I worried she was in a situation where she couldn't back out. I'm religious — I attend church and have prayed. I've been happy for others' detransitions and babies, and I've offered to DM and talk with people going through it. I now believe it's better and more in line with reality to accept yourself as a woman, even if that means dressing a bit manlier. I think social transitions almost always lead to medical transitions in the long run because you can't actually become the other sex. I'm critical of doctors profiting off 'mutilating someone unnecessarily' and of the emotional blackmail parents face ('Would you rather have a living son or a dead daughter?'). I'm also critical of the claim that not affirming trans kids causes suicide, asking where the child suicides throughout history are. I've advised people to stop binding since binders can damage the body, and I've suggested that masculine women, especially lesbian/bi women, are more likely to want to transition only because transitioning is so widely discussed and promoted today. I've reassured detransitioners that their voices and looks read female.