Усі історії

Упевнена з 15 до 28, а потім запитання, які все перевернули

Чоловік · Детранзиціонував(ла)159
Ці історії були узагальнені за допомогою ШІ.

На Reddit люди часто діляться своїм досвідом у кількох коментарях або постах. Щоб зробити цю інформацію більш доступною, detrans.ai збирає всі ці розрізнені частини в одне легке для читання узагальнення та хронологію. Усі системні промпти зазначені на сторінці промптів.

Іноді ШІ може галюцинувати або стверджувати речі, які не є правдою. Але загалом узагальнені історії є точним відображенням оригінальних коментарів користувачів.

Резюме

Я здійснив зворотний перехід після того, як від середини підліткового віку до кінця двадцятих був упевнений, що я транс, а тепер ідентифікую себе за своєю біологічною статтю, повністю деконструювавши свої попередні гендерно-ідеологічні переконання. Мені допомогли терплячі гендерно-критичні жінки, чиї запитання зруйнували мої погляди, і я пережив цю зміну як свого роду зраду й втрату, подібну до втрати релігії, в якій виріс. Я шкодую про виставу, яку підтримував, і рішуче застерігаю інших від незворотної операції, якщо в них є найменший сумнів. Я критикую транс-організації за те, що вважаю навмисним нагнітанням страху, і тепер маю гендерно-критичні погляди. Я чоловік і гей, і кажу це як факт, а не як образу.

Повна історія

I was absolutely certain I was trans from my mid-teens to my late twenties, and nobody could talk any sense into me — but I did in fact change my mind after all. I fitted all three definitions of being 'genuinely trans' (believing I was the opposite sex, experiencing debilitating dysphoria about my sex, and psychologically benefiting from cross-sex hormones and/or surgery) until I didn't. For a long time I kept up what I now see as a charade. The realisation that I didn't have to keep it up anymore — that I'd trapped myself in a Sisyphean challenge of my own making which I could in fact simply leave at any time — was so unbelievably liberating. It took me a while to fully understand that no matter what I'd done to my body I am literally my biological sex, and to disentangle my thoughts from the way I'd been conditioned to see sex and gender. My deconstruction happened gradually. I went from saying 'don't worry, guys, I'm not going to be one of those detrans folk!' to slowly deconstructing everything and finding I agreed with a lot of what the gender critical side was saying once I actually took the time to listen. The first time I decided to watch a 'terfy' video I had to force myself not to freak out; I deliberately chose the type of video I thought would be least offensive to me and still almost had a panic attack because I felt so ashamed about agreeing with her. I felt like I'd turned evil and was becoming the very thing I was afraid detransition would lead to. Some really nice, patient gender critical women helped — all they did was answer my questions and ask me some in return, but every question they asked, once I stopped combatively resisting and actually thought properly about it, caused my views to collapse in on themselves. Questions as simple as 'What is a woman?', 'What does living as a woman mean?', 'How can somebody be born in the wrong body?'. I realised defining gender (by which they really mean sex) based on stereotypes instead of biology was regressive. Once I'd extricated myself from the mess of gender ideology it became less and less possible for me to make sense of my previous beliefs, which had been almost entirely based in nebulous feelings. I was anchorless, and I was angry about it for quite a long time. The sense of betrayal, confusion, loss and nervousness about the future felt no different to when I'd suddenly stopped believing in the religion I was raised in, and I couldn't believe I'd fallen for it again. I now advise anyone with any doubts whatsoever not to get surgery: 'This is not something you can EVER reverse. You can always postpone something to a later date but you can't ever turn the clock back.' I also tell people that if you're male and solely attracted to other males you will always be a gay man no matter what cosmetic changes you make, and that denying that is what leads to a lot of trans-identified people's distress, as it did for me. I'm critical of trans organisations for framing the UK court decision as a 'new law' to instil unnecessary fear in young people.