Ці історії були узагальнені за допомогою ШІ.
На Reddit люди часто діляться своїм досвідом у кількох коментарях або постах. Щоб зробити цю інформацію більш доступною, detrans.ai збирає всі ці розрізнені частини в одне легке для читання узагальнення та хронологію. Усі системні промпти зазначені на сторінці промптів.
Іноді ШІ може галюцинувати або стверджувати речі, які не є правдою. Але загалом узагальнені історії є точним відображенням оригінальних коментарів користувачів.
Резюме
Я народилася жінкою і з дитинства визначала себе як транс-чоловік, соціально перейшла, поки моя мати намагалася вживати займенники він/його, але ніколи не отримувала гормонів чи операцій, бо батьки відмовили. Я здійснила десіст у 18 років, значною мірою тому, що мій теперішній партнер побачив і поважав мене як жінку, що зробило мене гордою за те, що я така. Тепер я жінка, яка здійснила детранзишн/десіст, на ім'я Ніккі, яка завдячує батькам захистом і тепер активно застерігає дітей в інтернеті не квапитися з переходом. Я ніколи не робила медичного переходу, тож не маю хірургічних жалів, але глибоко шкодую, як близько була і про роки, втрачені на віру, що я транс. Я критикую перехід для неповнолітніх, небінарних людей, які привласнюють ярлик транс, і онлайн-спільноту транс, яку вважаю сектантською.
Повна історія
I was born female, and even as a kid I was socially trans — I told my friends my parents were transphobic because they didn't agree I should transition, even though my mother at least tried to use he/him pronouns for me after calling me 'she' for 16 years. I never got hormones or surgeries; my parents refused to let me, and I now believe they were protecting me the way a parent should. I came out as trans and fully believed I was a transman. When I was young I took a quiz that told me I was transgender and I accepted it, partly as an escape from how much I hated myself — I felt I wasn't worth living, was taking up space, wasn't a beautiful girl, and would die alone, and I thought being something else would make me worth the air I breathe. I was extremely mentally ill and depressed, sad and angry all the time, and I look back at old fights with previous friends and see how angry at the world I was. I'm an artist, and I think that link mattered: artists are often introverts and chronically online, perfectionists who feel bad about themselves and their creations, and I fell into the camp of trying to become something I liked because I didn't like myself. Drawing myself as the opposite gender felt euphoric, a temporary relief. I dated multiple people, primarily other FtM trans people, while I identified as FtM.
The change came gradually. First I wanted to grow my hair out, justifying it with 'I might as well look like the most attractive woman I can be until I can officially transition,' though I always ended up cutting it again. Then I wanted to dress more feminine, wear dresses and skirts, justifying it as 'obviously I'm just a femboy, I'm still a man I just like some feminine things.' Meeting and then dating my current partner at 18 was the nail in the coffin. He hadn't been told I was trans — he saw me as a woman — and the way he respected me and found me beautiful as I was made me feel proud to be a woman and showed me why I had thought I was trans in the first place. I desisted when I turned 18, at which point I realized I was not trans. I was far more scared to come out as desisting than I had been coming out as trans, because I feared being told I had faked it to be trendy when I truly believed I was trans — and the trans community made sure that fear was justified, telling me I was being manipulated into thinking I wasn't trans.
It wasn't until this year, at 20, that I realized how terrible a decision I could have made if my parents hadn't stopped me. I see so many people my age detransitioning and think 'Oh my God. That could have been me.' If I could give advice to my younger self I wouldn't — instead I'd want to tell my parents at the time to take me to therapy and work on learning to love myself to prevent me from ever thinking I was trans. I did not go back to my birth name, Carlee, which I hate because it sounds ugly and always got the response 'Oh! Like iCarly!' When I believed I was trans I chose the name Leon, which I still like without animosity, though it's weird to hear. I tried Leona after desisting but it didn't stick, so I go by Nikki, a nickname for my middle name, and I'm content with it.
I have no ongoing medical needs since I never medically transitioned. Mentally, I was extremely ill and depressed while identifying as trans and even more depressed after; I was sad and angry constantly. I don't describe specific trauma beyond saying I held trauma and suffered for years because I was afraid of the consequences of telling someone, and I believe non-binary identification can come from trauma or confusion. My family supported me — they refused transition as a child and I credit them with protecting me. My current partner, whom I began dating at 18, was central to my desisting; I also had a girlfriend at one point whom I advised to leave a partner who wouldn't support her detransition journey. Sexually and romantically, while identifying as FtM I dated primarily FtM people but grew sick of it — I wanted to date someone who was actually a man, someone with a penis, because I'm not a lesbian and wasn't attracted to them romantically or sexually since they still had women's bodies.
I don't describe intense regret over medical changes since I had none, but I deeply regret how close I came and the lost years of believing I was trans; that realization has deepened over the past year rather than faded. I now think transition for children is something I'm very against — I draw the line at kids getting any hormones or surgeries, though socially being trans as a teenager is 'a bit irksome' but not permanent, and I believe adults' bodies are their own decision. I regularly try to warn kids online about how serious transition is, though they often blow me off as an uneducated bigot, which is heart-wrenching. I think the trans community is cult-like (Buck Angel explains it well), I'm skeptical of most people who claim to be trans unless they meet strict criteria (diagnosed dysphoria, surgery, therapy with a non-gender-affirming therapist, a known reason for being trans), I respect standard pronouns but refuse neopronouns, I believe non-binary should have a separate label and not be called trans, and I feel deeply disrespected when people try to 'educate' me on trans issues despite my first-hand experience — more offended than I ever was by misgendering or deadnaming.