Ці історії були узагальнені за допомогою ШІ.
На Reddit люди часто діляться своїм досвідом у кількох коментарях або постах. Щоб зробити цю інформацію більш доступною, detrans.ai збирає всі ці розрізнені частини в одне легке для читання узагальнення та хронологію. Усі системні промпти зазначені на сторінці промптів.
Іноді ШІ може галюцинувати або стверджувати речі, які не є правдою. Але загалом узагальнені історії є точним відображенням оригінальних коментарів користувачів.
Резюме
Я жінка, яка відмовилася від переходу, живу в Мельбурні, Австралія. Я використовувала транс-ярлик і чоловіче соціальне ім'я з 2010 року (у 21 рік) до кінця 2012 року, але ніколи не приймала гормони й не робила операцій, і здійснила детранзицію здебільшого через постійне неправильне звертання за гендером і соціальне виснаження. Читання радикальної феміністської літератури допомогло мені прийняти своє тіло, і відтоді я почала більше дотримуватися своєї релігії. Я зазнала масштабного сексуального насильства як від чоловіків, так і від жінок, боролася з тяжкою депресією (почала приймати лексапро на початку 2023 року) і підозрюю, що маю аутизм. Я підтримую право дорослих на перехід, але критикую медичний перехід для молодих людей і твердження гендерної ідеології, і заперечую проти того, щоб мене називали «cis» або «queer».
Повна історія
I was born female and grew up in Australia, raised in a religion from birth that I rejected at 17. I started using the trans label at 21, in 2010, after reading about being trans in books and then online — I read other people's accounts but didn't participate much in those forums. I came out as a trans man in 2011 and was offended when someone asked if I 'wanted to be a man', because I already believed I was male, even though I hadn't legally changed my name, had surgery, or started hormones.
I changed my outfits, hairstyle, name, and pronoun. I cut my hair, never wore skirts, dresses or makeup, bought clothes from men's shops, wore a single earring, and told people I identified as male. I moved to a different city and used a masculine social name there. I never took testosterone — I think the main reason was that I was in a relationship with an abusive heterosexual man who wouldn't have permitted it, and I didn't want to start T so I knew I probably couldn't pass anyway. I wanted chest surgery at first, but that desire faded (and later returned). At 22, I was convinced real men don't wear bras, so I wore a singlet under my t-shirt while visiting a hot country instead of a binder, and had to sit and catch my breath.
I detransitioned at the end of 2012, after about two years, mainly because people were being jerks about it — I was tired of being constantly misgendered, called a lesbian, and asked how I urinate. Coming out all the time was exhausting and I lost faith in others. When I moved back to my home town, nobody there was willing to call me by my birth name, so in 2014 I legally changed it to a different, common female name (I've described it as Alexandra to Sarah, though those aren't the real names) because people kept mispronouncing my birth name. My parents weren't supportive of the name change in 2014, but since 2019 they have used it in situations where they know I want others to. I'm comfortable with my immediate family still calling me 'Alex'.
I started identifying as trans in 2010, and I've said I was 21–23 during the period when I believed people were being deliberately transphobic when they used the pronoun they thought was right for me. I detransitioned at the end of 2012. I've described myself as desisted rather than fully detransitioned, since I only did social things — no hormones, no surgery, and I never told my family about my new pronoun or social name while I was in the other city.
I initially went back to my birth name after detransitioning. I later came across radical feminist literature, which was the reason I started genuinely accepting my body as it is — I no longer hate it, though I don't love it. I no longer want my breasts removed, but I've said I'm seriously considering a reduction, because so many men and women have abused me that I can't be comfortable with them as they are. Twitter started the process of my accepting my body. I don't feel like I'm 'trans but closeted' anymore.
The transition toward accepting my body progressed into wanting to become more observant in the religion I've believed in for about a decade — partly because of feeling connected to the idea that we are made in God's image and our bodies don't need fixing if our mind is causing distress, and partly because I wanted to meet people who don't believe a toddler who puts on a dress once is female and should be castrated. I find the argument that gender identity is like a religion persuasive, since it relies on belief in something unseen, like a soul. I've also said that being a boy or a girl doesn't require medical intervention, comparing it to not supporting removal of foreskins or clitorises.
I don't identify as trans these days, and I object to being called 'cis' — I don't identify with the female label or with women; I just accept that my body is female and use an accurate label, like calling myself human. I also reject the 'queer' label even when I've experienced same-sex attraction or felt asexual. My sexual orientation fluctuates; I don't want sex and have no interest in dating men. I've said I don't relate to women at all, but pretending to be a woman is less difficult for me than pretending to be a man. I'm currently a desisted female living in Melbourne.
I've been on antidepressants (Lexapro) — I was severely depressed in the 6–12 months before February 2023 and was riding the high of my first eight days on them. I've said I'm mentally ill and haven't made art for years due to ever-worsening depression, though I still appreciate it and went to the art gallery a few months prior. I suspect I'm autistic but am not diagnosed.
I've experienced extensive sexual violence. I didn't consider transitioning until after I was sexually assaulted many times, starting at 18. I wanted to be seen as male so men would stop raping me — their actions are the only reason I started to despise my body. Some of my rapists are female, which made me hate my body more. I've said same-sex female relationships are statistically more violent than heterosexual ones and that I've suffered a ton of sexual and physical assault from women, including rape. The years I spent looking like a butch lesbian were some of the only years I wasn't constantly being raped, so that part 'did kind of work'. I've been assaulted at lesbian-only events for years, most recently at the last one I attended, which was heavily sexualised. I've said I'm relieved I stopped trying to meet lesbians for friendship or dates.
I was in a loveless marriage at some point and am no longer in it. I dumped a boyfriend who was a serial rapist who had threatened to rape me; he also told me refusing sex with a trans people was bigotry, that convicted rapists don't belong in prison if trans, and that women and children wanting sex-segregated toilets need to get over it. He admitted to raping most of his ex-girlfriends and said it was justified. Ex-boyfriends repeatedly told me I was a lesbian, not to sleep with me but to make me miserable enough to do the dumping. I was in an abusive relationship with a hetero guy earlier who wouldn't have permitted testosterone.
I've had negative experiences with psychologists: one form asked my pronoun before they'd see me, another asked my sexual orientation (which I refused to answer, after which she laughed and called me 'queer'); another told me to just date trans men if I didn't want to be raped. I decided not to see a psychologist because her form asked 'what is your pronoun?'. An arts professor publicly announced my 'real' name to the class when I asked her to use my social name; I dropped out and failed the replacement class, and she blamed me. I've been repeatedly misgendered with 'they' by progressive people despite begging them to use 'she', including offline.
I've experienced hostility from people I'd consider on the left — someone I'd spent time with offline threatened me with physical violence when discussing this matter. I've been called a 'terf' for contacting someone about rape allegations against a person their website was platforming. I'm close to my family; my conservative dad tells me I'm not really a woman because I don't have a partner and have never given birth. I have a 6-year-old nephew. I cut two extended family members out of my life over name issues.
I regret the years spent trying to be seen as male and the exhaustion of coming out constantly, though I'm glad I didn't take testosterone. I've said I'm glad I didn't take T and that at least having breasts means I can breastfeed if I become a mother. I still don't really like having breasts. I've said I thought my life was over at 17 but at 33 realised I was wrong. I'm now 34 (as of February 2023). I don't have a partner.
I'm critical of transition for others in some respects — I think children under a certain age should get different support, and I think people should be absolutely sure before hormones or surgery — but I also say gender dysphoria is real and transitioning alleviates it for some, and that I support an adult's right to transition. I don't think everyone who transitions regrets it. I've objected to a post title claiming transitioning made someone's life better, saying it made me uncomfortable, while acknowledging some get lasting relief. I've pushed back against the sub becoming an echo chamber and against people arguing no one is genuinely trans. I haven't done formal activism, but I graffitied a university poster asking 'Do you identify as female?' with 'I am a woman', and I've reported posts to mods. I've advocated for people to be able to say 'I am a woman' when asked their pronouns.