Tất cả câu chuyện

Một bình luận viên chưa từng chuyển giới, lại đưa lời khuyên về liều lượng

Nam · Đã từ bỏ263
Những câu chuyện này đã được tóm tắt bằng AI.

Trên Reddit, ngưởi thường chia sẻ kinh nghiệm của họ qua nhiều bình luận hoặc bài đăng. Để làm cho thông tin này dễ tiếp cận hơn, detrans.ai thu thập tất cả những mảnh thông tin rải rác đó thành một bản tóm tắt và dòng thời gian dễ đọc. Tất cả lệnh hệ thống được ghi chú trên trang lệnh.

Đôi khi AI có thể ảo giác hoặc nói những điều không đúng sự thật. Nhưng nhìn chung, các câu chuyện tóm tắt phản ánh chính xác các bình luận gốc của ngưởi dùng.

Tóm tắt

Tôi là một người bình luận trong cộng đồng detrans, người chưa bao giờ mô tả bản thân đã chuyển giới; tôi là một người đàn ông có bạn gái ba năm tính đến năm 2020. Suốt năm 2019–2020, tôi lập luận mạnh mẽ rằng giới tính không thể thay đổi, rằng chuyển giới biến con người thành bệnh nhân y tế suốt đời và rằng người detrans nên hồi phục qua chế độ ăn, tập luyện nặng, giấc ngủ, giảm thời gian nhìn màn hình và thời gian ngoài trời. Tôi ủng hộ việc nâng cao nhận thức công chúng chống lại việc chuyển giới của người trẻ, thúc giục mọi người liên hệ truyền thông và công khai thù địch với y học chuyển giới, các subreddit trans và cha mẹ ủng hộ, đôi khi dùng lời lăng mạ và tu từ ưu sinh. Tôi đưa ra lời khuyên chi tiết về liều testosterone, HCG và hồi phục sau HRT. Tôi không mô tả bất kỳ khó chịu giới tính cá nhân, can thiệp y tế, phẫu thuật hay hối hận của riêng mình.

Toàn bộ câu chuyện

I came to the detrans community in 2019 as a commenter rather than a poster, and almost everything I wrote was advice, argument, or criticism aimed at other people rather than a narration of my own life. That said, my own situation leaks through in a few places. I am a man. In March 2020 I told someone who called me an incel: "How am I incel if I have gf (real woman that can give birth and doesn't need surgery to remove Adams apple) of 3 years?" So by then I had a girlfriend of three years, which puts the start of that relationship around 2017. I have never described dysphoria, coming out, hormones, surgery, or a detransition of my own in this transcript, and I am not going to invent one. What I have is a strongly held set of convictions about transition, formed apparently from observation, argument, and community participation rather than from a stated personal medical history. My core position, repeated across dozens of comments, is that transition is impossible and that sex is fixed. In July 2019 I wrote: "on genetically and cellular level you cannot transition" and "Your gender was decided in the womb prior to your birth. It will be like that forever after you die as well, from the bone structure you will leave behind." In December 2019: "You're born male or female. Can't change that as most detrans found out." I framed trans people as ill or deluded, cited the "41%" suicide statistic repeatedly as a warning, and said things like "Being a medical patient for life is not worth it" and "You become a medical patient for life, needing to pin every week. You will cause irreversible damage to the body, the younger you are the more irreversible." I was very interested in the mechanics of hormones and recovery, and I dispensed detailed, confident advice about them: diet (eggs, honey, beef, broccoli, salmon, watermelon for arginine, red grapes to "block out some estrogen"), heavy contact sport and lifting to raise testosterone, sleep, screen reduction, and time outdoors. I told people their bodies would "cleanse itself over time" and that recovery would take one to three years. In May 2020 I discussed testosterone dosing at length, comparing 250mg/wk to a steroid cycle, 100-125mg to a TRT "cruise" dose, and explained how HCG restarts endogenous LH/FSH production after exogenous hormones shut the testicles down. I also argued that dysphoria "is more like autism, hard to get rid off." I gave blunt, sometimes harsh personal advice: "You took the easy way out," "You are a man not a bitch, act like it," "fix your limp wrists," "Cut out gay shit like yaoi." I advised one person to try acting straight to win over a disapproving father, and told another to "Just be gay or something." I was openly hostile to transition medicine, to the medical professionals who provide it ("Can you not sue him? That is disgusting"), to mainstream media, and to trans subreddits, which I called "a hugbox for deluded people." I used slurs and derogatory language freely and acknowledged it: "Sometimes if you want to stay in positive rating you need to sugar coat it but I don't like doing that. Maybe a bit mean spirited but the message is clear." I also expressed a eugenic-tinged view of transition, writing in September 2019 that trans people "already going infertile from hrt, so it's safe bet their disease will die with them," and that "only the strong survive and reproduce." I was suspicious of parents who support trans children, blaming "brain damaged hyper liberal parents, usually the mother," and cited the Chris Chan case as a cautionary tale about passive parenting of an autistic boy. On gay rights I was ambivalent: I accepted that some people are gay ("Just be gay or something"), advised someone on reconciling with a father over it, but also lumped LGB together dismissively, said "Transphobia does not exist," and wrote "I was happier when the movement was underground." I wanted detransitioners to go public: "The next best thing you can do is raise awareness for this so young people don't see transition as a legitimate band aid," and "Reach out to the media. If you end it they win." I never described therapy, a diagnosis, an adverse medical event, or a specific regret of my own, because I never described undergoing transition. My whole presence in this community has been as an observer and commentator.