Những câu chuyện này đã được tóm tắt bằng AI.
Trên Reddit, ngưởi thường chia sẻ kinh nghiệm của họ qua nhiều bình luận hoặc bài đăng. Để làm cho thông tin này dễ tiếp cận hơn, detrans.ai thu thập tất cả những mảnh thông tin rải rác đó thành một bản tóm tắt và dòng thời gian dễ đọc. Tất cả lệnh hệ thống được ghi chú trên trang lệnh.
Đôi khi AI có thể ảo giác hoặc nói những điều không đúng sự thật. Nhưng nhìn chung, các câu chuyện tóm tắt phản ánh chính xác các bình luận gốc của ngưởi dùng.
Tóm tắt
Tôi là một người nam detrans, chuyển giới năm 18 tuổi, sống như nữ khoảng 1,5 năm trên HRT và chuyển giới ngược khoảng một năm trước. Giờ tôi là sinh viên đại học 20 tuổi sống như một nam giới bình thường. Tôi chuyển giới vì trầm cảm nặng, tự làm hại bản thân và cảm giác không đủ nam tính sau khi bị bắt nạt vì nét nữ tính ở tuổi thiếu niên — và dù hormone ban đầu giúp ích, cuối cùng tôi mệt mỏi với lo lắng về giới liên tục và viễn cảnh dùng hormone và phẫu thuật suốt đời. Tôi giảm HRT, chuyển giới ngược xã hội dần dần với chút phản đối từ bạn bè và vẫn rất hài lòng, dù tôi còn chút mô ngực vĩnh viễn và đôi khi vẫn khó chịu giới. Tôi chỉ hối hận chút ít về việc chuyển giới và coi việc chuyển giới ngược là đáng giá 100%, sức khỏe tâm thần giờ tốt. Tôi không chống lại việc chuyển giới của người khác nhưng khuyến khích cân nhắc cẩn thận và ủng hộ sự chừng mực trong cộng đồng để tránh bị loại trừ.
Toàn bộ câu chuyện
I was born male and detransitioned back to living as a man; I'm 20 years old now and a university student. I transitioned at 18, coming out and living as a woman, and I stayed on HRT for about 1.5 years before tapering off.
Before transition I was absolutely miserable — I had depression, I was cutting myself, and I wasn't particularly keen on being alive. I thought of transition as the only solution that could possibly help, though I didn't really expect it to work; I just didn't give a shit about my life at that point, so I figured I might as well try. A big driver was that I felt too unmasculine — I'd been bullied as a teen for my feminine traits, and I had an overall negative view of men. Before coming out, I shaved my legs once and got called a faggot quite a lot of times for it, and even well-meaning people made comments. I also had genuine gender dysphoria, but I mainly wanted to look masculine because that's what society respects in men.
To my surprise, transition actually did work. After a couple of months on hormones and a lot of time around other trans people — which mattered a lot because I had few friends at the time — my life improved significantly. My depression went away, I stopped cutting myself, and I started to actually care about my life. I started university and found passion, friends, and a purpose. I was never especially effeminate — no makeup, just jeans, hoodies, t-shirts, rarely shaved body hair — and I started to dislike my body significantly less.
After a bit more than a year on HRT I realized the transition didn't matter to me as much as other things in my life, and I got tired of all the annoying stuff about being trans. I was scared the depression would come back if I stopped, but I tapered off — first the anti-androgens, then the estrogen — and didn't feel any different. After a couple of weeks my libido came back and my penis started working again; I was mostly indifferent and excited that my mood hadn't changed. After about 3 months off HRT with nothing getting worse, I committed to detransition.
Social detransition scared me — I didn't want people to think I was an idiot. About a month later I started telling friends, deliberately making it as small a deal as possible, and it worked: no one really gave a fuck. I changed my name back at university by email (they're trans-friendly) and started presenting male again, though really I just wore t-shirts and jeans with different cuts and nobody noticed. I considered cutting my hair but kept it. I was only about half a year off HRT, so unless I introduced myself with my clearly male name, people just thought I was a masculine woman — which is socially accepted where I live. This 'gradual detransition' worked out well.
I now realize a few things that contributed to my transition. Once I addressed the leftover feelings from being bullied as a teen for my feminine traits, and my overall negative views of men, the intensity of my gender dysphoria lessened a lot. I also think there's pressure in LGBT communities to find the 'right' sexual identity. I've noted that Blanchard's theory about male transitioners might have been true for transitioners from back in the day, but most younger male (de)transitioners I've talked to don't fit it.
What moved me toward detransition was partly getting tired of the constant gender thinking — I passed even in sweatpants and a t-shirt, but I still felt anxious about not slipping up, and I realized the gender thing would never leave my mind as long as I stayed transitioned, since I'd always know I was born male and would need hormones for the rest of my life. I also didn't want surgery, which seemed like an eventual necessity for trans women who want to forget being trans, with scarring, regret risk, and financial disruption. Watching videos from a detransitioned guy helped me a lot.
Now, about a year off HRT, I'm very content. My life is that of a typical 20-year-old uni student without any weird gender stuff. I do regret transitioning a little bit — I have very small permanent breast tissue now and look like I'm 15 — but it's really not that big of a deal for me. I still occasionally experience gender dysphoria or miss some things I had when transitioned, but detransition was 100% worth it. I have good mental and physical health, I'm doing great at university, and I'm excited about my future, which I never could have imagined in my teenage years. The best thing about detransitioning is that I simply don't have to give a shit about all the gender nonsense anymore.
On transition for others, I'm not opposed — I've told people considering it that ultimately it's their call, while suggesting they might try not caring about being perceived as male or female in low-stakes scenarios first, and I've encouraged people to consider other factors influencing their dysphoria. I've also advised people in the subreddit to tone down 'GC lingo' so the community doesn't get banned, and I've expressed hope that Littman's research on detransitioners turns out to be high quality.