Tất cả câu chuyện

Một cậu bé hoài nghi đã chọn không chuyển giới

Nam · Đã từ bỏ945
Những câu chuyện này đã được tóm tắt bằng AI.

Trên Reddit, ngưởi thường chia sẻ kinh nghiệm của họ qua nhiều bình luận hoặc bài đăng. Để làm cho thông tin này dễ tiếp cận hơn, detrans.ai thu thập tất cả những mảnh thông tin rải rác đó thành một bản tóm tắt và dòng thời gian dễ đọc. Tất cả lệnh hệ thống được ghi chú trên trang lệnh.

Đôi khi AI có thể ảo giác hoặc nói những điều không đúng sự thật. Nhưng nhìn chung, các câu chuyện tóm tắt phản ánh chính xác các bình luận gốc của ngưởi dùng.

Tóm tắt

Tôi là một chàng trai trẻ đang đặt câu hỏi, không phải người detrans, đến cộng đồng này vào tháng 6 năm 2022 vì tôi thấy các subreddit chuyển giới phổ biến quá nhanh khi gọi người ta là chuyển giới. Tôi có trải nghiệm tự ái ái nữ (chủ yếu liên quan thủ dâm hơn là mặc đồ khác giới), sở thích yuri, và sự ngưỡng mộ/ghen tị với phụ nữ, nhưng tôi thích giọng thấp, lông cơ thể và mặt, bạn nam, quần áo và sở thích nam, và tôi hoàn toàn thoải mái sống như một người nam. Tôi được nuôi trong một gia đình toàn nữ, nơi nam giới được miêu tả là xấu xa, bạo lực và nguy hiểm, điều tôi nghĩ khiến tôi khó chắc chắn về giới của mình; tôi cũng là một thiếu niên mọt sách bị bắt nạt, bị cuốn vào các tranh luận giới trên mạng, khiêu dâm và hệ tư tưởng chính trị/giới. Tôi quyết định không chuyển giới, bỏ khiêu dâm, và giờ khuyên người khác — đặc biệt thiếu niên nhỏ tuổi — tránh xa các không gian trực tuyến tập trung vào giới, thực hiện khám phá bản thân hoặc trị liệu, và tìm hình mẫu nam giới không độc hại, đồng thời cảnh báo «chuyển giới sẽ hủy hoại cuộc đời bạn». Tôi có quan điểm chỉ trích về điều người khác gọi là hệ tư tưởng giới, định nghĩa giới sinh học qua nhiễm sắc thể, và xem bản dạng chuyển giới là điều bạn làm, không phải điều bạn là.

Toàn bộ câu chuyện

I'm a teenage boy who came to the detrans community in June 2022 not because I had transitioned, but because I was questioning my gender and wanted a more skeptical perspective than the mainstream trans subreddits offered. I laid out my reasons for and against thinking I might be trans. On the "might be trans" side, I listed that I suffer from autogynephilia, that I'd recently developed a Yuri fetish, that I don't like being violent or fighting other guys, and that I'm very emotional and romantic. On the other side, I listed that I like my deep voice, I've always had more male friends, I like manly clothes, most of my interests are manly or ungendered like football and video games, I like my facial and body hair, and I'd always liked being considered male without a problem with it. I clarified that my autogynephilia isn't really about crossdressing — I didn't like wearing feminine clothes — but more about masturbation, so I concluded I didn't need to transition for it. I said I was "surely ain't gonna transition" and that my autogynephilia is pretty low, so I could satisfy it with masturbation. I told people I was totally okay living as a male, swinging between femininity and masculinity as I wanted but keeping happy as a man. I noted that some trans activists on Reddit had told me I was "a trans girl in denial," which I rejected. I mentioned I was a week into a porn-free streak and doing well with it. I masturbated only with fantasy, swinging between autogynephilia and straight arousal. In June 2022 I also posted a question asking whether men being seen as violent and evil favors transsexualism. I explained that since I was a kid, family and people around me — especially women — taught me that men are evil, violent, that old men are ugly and shouldn't be examples, that men are inferior to women and less smart, and that all men will be rapers or pedophiles. I said this rhetoric made me feel insecure about my gender identity. I later added that I was raised in an all-feminine family where men were always seen as rapers, pedophiles, and evil while girls were pretty, smart, and not dangerous. I developed a theory that when people don't feel their body or character similar to others of their gender, they can create a mechanism of identifying with the other gender. I advised a questioning girl that lots of girls like masculine clothes and that doesn't make you trans, and that dysphoria about not being as feminine as other girls isn't causal. I recommended she ask herself why she started questioning her gender identity. I told her she should try to overcome her hate for women, recognizing it as trauma. I shared my own background: I'm a nerdy, introverted boy who was bullied a lot, fell into an addiction to internet and porn, and got really into political debate, which brought me into contact with gender ideologies. My advice to others in similar positions was to stop staying on the internet, stop thinking about gender, live life alone for a while to value what's good for you, and find different role models — musicians, artists, writers who aren't extremely masculine — because the web damages young boys with ultra-masculine roles and cruel mentalities. I told a 14-year-old they shouldn't even be thinking about transition. I told someone dealing with what I recognized as transOCD to quit Reddit and social media, stop giving a fuck, and stop doing compulsions, saying I'd done the same and recovered in a few months. I described a personal experience of admiring women: as a straight guy, whenever I see a beautiful or smart girl, I feel something romantic but different — I want to be with her, connect with her, sometimes imitate her, and I see her as perfect and superior and want to worship and envy her, sometimes even wanting to be her. I related this to what others described as autohomoeroticism or gender envy, saying I experience the same as a cis male toward lesbian women. I told someone struggling with similar feelings that what helped me was understanding that to be male you only have to be a biological one — there's nothing else to it — and I asked them to reflect on why they admire and idolize women so much. I described feeling extreme social pressure and toxic masculinity making me feel like a "false man" and that the only worthwhile life was as a girl because I was "a failure as a guy." I said the best way to deal with it is to change companies, models, and views slowly. I recommended overcoming shame first, since shame can make autogynephilia stronger because we get addicted to anxious feelings, then embracing the fantasy in a conscious, moderate way, separating fantasy from reality, which makes it weaker. I offered to DM a questioning male and told someone "Live your life. You can enjoy yourself and the world. You can be feminine, masculine, GNC, whatever you want. You can be a father one day, or don't if you want. Transition will destroy your life." I also said "Trans identity doesn't make you feel good, it is an illusion" and advised someone to find purpose and goals rather than euphoria in gender. I held and expressed a number of strong views: I defined man and woman by XY/XX chromosomes and primary and secondary sexual characteristics, calling DSDs "illnesses" and saying changing the concepts of man and woman for someone with illnesses is mad. I argued gender is sex's metaphysics, that gender ideology connects to Marx via Marcuse, Foucault, and neomarxism, and that it stems from idealism mixed with postmodernism. I said men are not oppressors — patriarchal heteronormativity is — and that benefiting from an oppressive system isn't the same as being the oppressor. I argued both men and women have difficult lives and opposed "gender war." I said that a lot of AGP men transition to female to satisfy their fetish and escape shame, while females more easily accept having a fetish and detransition because social pressure about gender roles isn't as high. I told someone "Trans is something you do, not something you are" and suggested they attempt detransitioning. I never described undergoing hormones, surgery, or any transition myself; my participation was as a questioning teen boy seeking and giving advice.