Những câu chuyện này đã được tóm tắt bằng AI.
Trên Reddit, ngưởi thường chia sẻ kinh nghiệm của họ qua nhiều bình luận hoặc bài đăng. Để làm cho thông tin này dễ tiếp cận hơn, detrans.ai thu thập tất cả những mảnh thông tin rải rác đó thành một bản tóm tắt và dòng thời gian dễ đọc. Tất cả lệnh hệ thống được ghi chú trên trang lệnh.
Đôi khi AI có thể ảo giác hoặc nói những điều không đúng sự thật. Nhưng nhìn chung, các câu chuyện tóm tắt phản ánh chính xác các bình luận gốc của ngưởi dùng.
Tóm tắt
Tôi là một người nữ tự kỷ 35 tuổi, lớn lên trong một gia đình nghiêm khắc về tôn giáo, bắt đầu tự nhận là non-binary và sau đó cố ý chấp nhận một hình thức không giới tính để tránh sự chú ý tình dục không mong muốn, điều đó khiến tôi mang nỗi xấu hổ về giới tính của chính mình. Giờ tôi thích làm phụ nữ, và trị liệu — bao gồm IFS — đã giúp tôi đón nhận bản sắc của mình sau những giai đoạn nặng nề. Tôi đến với cộng đồng detrans trong sự bối rối trước việc thiếu bằng chứng ủng hộ chuyển giới y tế, đặc biệt cho trẻ em, và giờ tôi vận động cho các tiêu chuẩn chăm sóc tốt hơn và sự đồng thuận có hiểu biết, tin rằng những người chuyển giới ngược là những tiếng nói quan trọng nhất trong cuộc tranh luận này. Tôi có quan điểm tinh tế: không nên bác bỏ việc y học hóa cho một số người trưởng thành, nhưng mô hình khẳng định và việc tiếp cận testosterone dễ dàng khiến tôi lo ngại. Tôi tích cực hỗ trợ những người đang cân nhắc hoặc trải qua chuyển giới ngược, và chỉ trích điều tôi thấy là động lực văn hóa thuần khiết trong khái niệm «gia đình được chọn» của LGBT.
Toàn bộ câu chuyện
I came to the detrans community because I had become disturbed by the lack of evidence in the medical literature supporting medical transition for gender dysphoria. I started combing through the literature last month, hoping it would enlighten me and cure my trans skepticism, only to be horrified by what has been permitted regarding children without the evidence to support it. I find that skepticism is quickly regarded as transphobic and silenced, both in online forums and within universities.
On my own background: I was raised very religious and I am on the autism spectrum. I was told in rigid terms what a woman was, and as an autist I thought, if I'm not that, I must be nonbinary. The other factor was sexual harassment. In my hometown, if I wore makeup or form-fitting clothes it was no problem, but when I moved I started to get unwanted attention. That was when I started to present myself in a more sexless way. I don't think there is anything wrong with that — I was able to avoid unwanted attention. The problem was how it affected my identity as a woman and how I saw myself. I had a lot of shame about my sex.
I am 35 years old. I have had hard periods that have lasted years, but the important thing has been being consistent in moving forward; at some point you wake up and recognize you haven't had difficult thoughts and feelings in months. Therapy helped me a lot with accepting my identity, and I like being a woman now because I am older. If someone has trauma, I would suggest trying IFS (Internal Family Systems).
I care a great deal about others who are trying to decide about transition. When someone writes to me about considering testosterone, I tell them it is a really difficult space to be in — hard to be in therapy because therapists tend to be biased one way or another, and hard to be in the detrans space if you don't feel your story is fully represented there. I think it is good to ask yourself how permanent changes to your body might actually feel, not the social media portrayal of the perfect transmasc identity. Not everyone has regrets and some people do. I am happy when someone is taking those decisions seriously; the ease of access to permanently life-altering testosterone is concerning to me. I have pointed people to the Therapy First website, which has a page of studies on alternative treatments, though I have not read through the literature yet.
I believe detransitioners really are the most important group for advocating for better care, because these are people who have actually lived through the reality of being medicalised when suffering from GD. It is no coincidence that there is so much effort going into the silencing of this population. I noted that research may be coming out of the UK, and that since the Trump administration banned funding for GAC in minors even for research it will be difficult to do a true study comparing treatments. In 5, 10, 20 years we will probably see a fallout from the liberal prescription of GAC and the affirmation model in therapy — though that doesn't give us better evidence, just more information regarding harm caused.
I hold a nuanced view: there are many detransitioners, particularly those who went through transition as young adults, who feel hurt by their medical providers, and there is concern when someone presenting with serious mental health disorders is treated for GD with the assumption that it is the main driver. At the same time, there are many adults who are happy with their transition and experience a decrease in GD, suggesting medicalization shouldn't be off the table — but there needs to be better standards of care and informed consent. I also think there are too many reactionary takes on transgender issues; we need to actually look at GD and what is underlying it, and the "woke mind virus" framing is entirely unhelpful. I have encouraged people to find a truly unbiased therapist, and I have expressed strong interest in research being shared with me.
On the LGBT community, I have said that while it has this whole concept of "chosen family," it still has a lot of the same toxic patterns as the "unaccepting family" — it becomes a purity culture in a whole new way while claiming to celebrate authenticity while encouraging conformity. I have also told someone who sounded very depressed and isolated that their sense of reality seemed to be being influenced by the Internet, that they would likely be much happier after building community and developing real-world hobbies, that their envy seemed rooted in low self-esteem, and that I would encourage them to investigate their family relationships and any trauma related to neglect; from their description, their happiness seemed to have much more to do with mental health difficulties than gender dysphoria. I told them I was older than them at 35 and that they grew up with COVID and social isolation being replaced by online communities — not their fault, and something they could move past into a life of self-acceptance and meaning. I also thanked someone for sharing, saying I was really trying to understand better in order to support others, and I have expressed admiration for someone pursuing a lawsuit, saying a lawsuit not only is for you but helps others who have been or will be harmed, and that it is admirable in this age of censorship to have your voice heard.