在Discord上用女性代词两年,没用激素,也不后悔
男性 · 已放弃957
这些故事已使用AI进行摘要。
在Reddit上,人们经常在多个评论或帖子中分享他们的经历。为了使这些信息更易于访问,detrans.ai 将所有这些分散的片段收集到一个易于阅读的摘要和时间线中。所有系统提示词都在提示词页面上注明。
有时AI可能会产生幻觉或陈述不真实的内容。但一般来说,摘要故事是用户原始评论的准确反映。
摘要
我是一名去性别转换的男性,从未进行过医学性别转换,只是在新冠疫情期间开始的约两年里,在网上使用女性名字和代词。如今我认定自己不是跨性别者,也不喜欢'desister'(退出者)这个标签。我认为我对自己跨性别的认同,源于童年创伤、社交孤立、保守的父母、对色情和男性气质的羞耻感、可能的自闭症,以及类似强迫症(OCD)的强迫性思维,而这些又被网上的跨性别社群所助长。一次由药物引发的灵性体验,以及离开跨性别Discord服务器,帮助我摆脱了那种认同,我此前感受到的性别焦虑也随之消失。目前我正在处理社交焦虑和认同问题,处于无性恋边缘,我以批判态度反对网上的跨性别意识形态,同时向他人推荐非肯定性疗法(non-affirming therapy)。
完整故事
I was born male. I never medically transitioned — the only things I ever did were grow my hair out and go by a female name and pronouns online, among strangers. I never even socially transitioned in real life, so I don't really consider myself a desister; I just consider myself not trans.
Looking back, I think I convinced myself I was trans instead of dealing with my actual issues. It started during COVID as a hyperfixation that got out of control, and it only lasted about 2 years for me. I had identified as MTF, but I've never been a feminine male — I just don't adhere to a lot of the more macho male things. Somehow I got the idea that I could be trans and found myself trying to make myself more feminine because I thought I had to be like that in order to be valid. Once I stopped being trans I never had any interest in the stuff I used to pretend to like.
Several factors fed into it. I had conservative parents, and finding porn on the internet made me feel ashamed of being male, including being attracted to women — I think that was a big factor in wanting to escape being male. I also felt like I wasn't living up to the social expectations of being a man. I was surrounded by people in online trans Discord servers who constantly gaslit me, and uncritically affirming communities distorted my sense of self to the point where I didn't recognize I was playing a character. I also used drugs to cope with what I called dysphoria.
I noticed that the more time I spent entertaining the fantasy, the worse my dysphoria got in the real world. Realizing that made me drop the whole trans thing. I also realized that most of my hatred of being male was based on my own stereotypes of what a male is supposed to be. Once I left every single trans Discord I started to feel better about myself. After one drug trip I noticed I no longer felt that obsession with thinking about how my life would be better if I had been born female — it was all a lie. I described the realization as feeling like a switch flipped, and I later had a drug-induced spiritual experience that changed everything by making me think, 'what if I died right now? Do I really want to waste the time I have in this life on this nonsense?' I also felt like some sort of godlike presence allowed me to escape this mental prison.
I think my issues were rooted in childhood trauma, social isolation, and an unstable sense of self where I would adopt the personalities of the people around me. I went into isolation as part of a self-discovery process but got sidetracked by gender ideology. I think I might be autistic. I also suspect I had some form of OCD where the obsession was caused by negative feelings and the compulsion was to think about it obsessively. I used to feel like a brother around women and then morph into a woman around men; since the trans phase stopped I've been working on fixing that, and while I'm not completely there yet, it's easier to talk to people without being constantly anxious.
Regarding sexuality: I felt like I was bi all the way back in middle school, then repressed it until 2020, when engaging with the trans community led me to become trans. I noticed I felt like I could be with men or women as a woman, but could only be with women as a man. Since going back to identifying as male, my preference for men has been basically zero — I guess it was meta attraction. I'm borderline asexual now, though I'm not too worried about it because I feel I'm too mentally screwed up to be with anyone right now.
I went to a psychiatrist to try to figure out what was actually wrong with me, though I planned to avoid mentioning the trans topic to her. I don't think I have the right temperament for counseling, especially on this subject. I've learned that the #1 step is to stop calling it gender dysphoria — using that term prevented me from seeing the root of the issue. Most of my problems don't stem from being male, but from how I feel about being male, how society treats me as a male, and how I feel about that treatment.
I don't regret specific medical changes since I had none, but I do regret the time and mental energy lost to the identity. I now take pride in how I look and work with what I have rather than agonizing over what I could have looked like as a woman. I prefer not to label myself as desister or detransitioner — I dislike the term 'desister' because it sounds like 'repressing' rather than just not being trans. I don't really believe in God but feel something like a spiritual experience helped me escape.
I have a few online friends going through the same thing, and my youngest brother is too, which is breaking my heart because I don't know what to do. I want to help others like me realize that transition isn't the answer. I believe there are some genuinely trans people, but the vast majority of online trans people don't seem to be. I've been critical of trans communities online, comparing gender ideology to a drug and describing places like egg_irl as psychological warfare. I recommend therapy and finding a non-affirming therapist to others going through this, while noting I wouldn't recommend the things I did to let go of these ideas.