被一路推着走向FTM,又回到中性偏男的打扮
女性 · 已去转变92
这些故事已使用AI进行摘要。
在Reddit上,人们经常在多个评论或帖子中分享他们的经历。为了使这些信息更易于访问,detrans.ai 将所有这些分散的片段收集到一个易于阅读的摘要和时间线中。所有系统提示词都在提示词页面上注明。
有时AI可能会产生幻觉或陈述不真实的内容。但一般来说,摘要故事是用户原始评论的准确反映。
摘要
我生为女性,曾一度认同自己是FTM、使用睾酮并追求平胸,此后完成了退跨,认同自己是butch女性或跨男性气质者。我对自己的女性身体比以往任何时候都更平静,把自己看作「一个改造了自己身体的butch」,而不是一个男人。我认为我的部分过渡源于围绕我不符合性别规范的社会压力,以及在性别焦虑诊断后被推上通往FTM的快车道。如今我批评「真正的跨性别」这一概念,并支持在任何医疗过渡之前进行更多的自我反思。我是双性恋,目前活在阳刚与阴柔之间的地带让我感到自在。
完整故事
I was born female and identified as trans for a period, taking testosterone and pursuing a flat chest, before detransitioning and coming to identify as a butch woman or transmasculine person. I've described myself as 'a butch who has modified my body' rather than 'a man trapped in a woman's body,' and I've said I feel more at peace with my female body than ever before.
What pushed me toward transition included social pressures: feminine lesbians made hateful comments about my clothes and hair, while men were ironically more tolerant of me. I spent time in mainstream intersectional feminist and witchcraft communities that felt aggressively feminine, and I've always felt more comfortable around gay men and FTM/transmasculine people. Straight men took my dysphoria symptoms personally — they read my need to keep my hair short and discomfort in bed as evidence I didn't like men at all, and I let those accusations get to me. I also felt obligated to identify as FTM because I benefited from hormones and wanted a flat chest, and people told me that identifying as anything other than a man meant my dysphoria wasn't real.
It took me until my mid-to-late twenties to come to terms with the causes of my social dysphoria. I've reflected that when diagnosed with dysphoria, people put you on a fast track to FTM and don't offer other options. Meeting gay FTMs helped me come to terms with my attraction to men — once dysphoria was no longer present, I realized I did actually want to date some guys. I am bi.
On detransition and self-reflection, I've argued that the 'real trans' concept doesn't hold up: bodybuilders who take testosterone without identifying as men don't develop dysphoria, butch women who get top surgery don't give themselves dysphoria, yet women who fit the classic trans narrative can still detransition with regret. I find the realization that I can't change my sex but can modify my body if I choose to be freeing. I've criticized trans activists for treating self-reflection questions — like whether someone is a tomboy/butch or has a history of abuse or misogyny — as conversion therapy, and for accusing detransitioners of stealing resources. I think the 'real trans with real dysphoria' narrative comes from fear: the idea that transition doesn't always cure dysphoria makes people uncomfortable, so they construct the narrative to justify their own choices rather than face that there may have been other options for their mental health.
I currently think of myself as either transmasculine or just a butch woman, and I've stopped caring whether people think my label is 'valid.' Leaning into the in-between feels more comfortable and gives me more realistic expectations of my body; trying to be just a guy felt like chasing an unachievable goal. I've noted that in my area butch is seen as basically closeted FTM, and that in 'woke' areas butches and FTMs are expected to stay quiet. I've offered support to others questioning their dysphoria, encouraging them to ask whether it's social or body-focused and whether body dysphoria is caused or exacerbated by social situations.