为逃离家暴而跨性别——而手术并没有解决它
女性 · 已去转变348
这些故事已使用AI进行摘要。
在Reddit上,人们经常在多个评论或帖子中分享他们的经历。为了使这些信息更易于访问,detrans.ai 将所有这些分散的片段收集到一个易于阅读的摘要和时间线中。所有系统提示词都在提示词页面上注明。
有时AI可能会产生幻觉或陈述不真实的内容。但一般来说,摘要故事是用户原始评论的准确反映。
摘要
我是一个经历了去转换的女性,曾以男性身份生活,接受了双侧乳房切除术并服用睾酮,我在2021年之前几年去转换。我部分是为了逃离家中的性虐待和应对不安而转换,但它并没有管好我的不安,我不得不对自己的动机诚实。我后悔双侧乳房切除术(我希望当时做的是keyhole)以及服用睾酮,尽管我现在感觉更好,并通过专注于爱好来管理残余的不安。我从未告诉父母我去转换了,但其他大多数人一直是支持的,我仍拥有我的伴侣。我仍批评双方制造恐惧的策略,并希望在去转换问题上进行诚实、有同理心的对话。
完整故事
I read Irreversible Damage in early 2021 and it made me feel sad because it made me reflect on my own lived experiences. I feel like a pariah for detransitioning, and it was painful to walk away from my friends in the trans community. Sometimes I want to talk about detransitioning but I'm afraid people won't understand or assume I'm hateful and harming the trans community. I think it's painful to talk about detransitioning because we're forced to be so honest with ourselves about what really was going on inside. For me, I had sexual abuse at home and I wanted to escape it. Detransitioning didn't only mean publicly stating I'm wrong and walking back on 'testimony' I gave supporting the trans community, but being painfully honest about stuff I wanted to bury. I feel like I'm still in the closet.
I transitioned and lived as a man, passed as male, but was consistently treated like I was effeminate and small — the whole macho thing let people push me around, for example for promotions and opportunities at work. I had a bilateral mastectomy (top surgery) with no reconstruction, and I took testosterone for a period of time. I've been detransitioned for several years now (as of early 2021). Since detransitioning I'm read as a masculine woman, and it's much easier for me socially — I feel like I'm read for who I am, which ironically is what I wanted out of transitioning.
I went back to living as a woman because I thought it would help me cope more productively with my dysphoria. It wasn't like one day I woke up and felt I'd made a horrible mistake — it was a process. It was painful because I had to be more honest around the motivations for transitioning. I am doing better now after detransitioning, but I think I still could have been happy as a trans man. What I wanted was to manage my dysphoria, and transitioning didn't get me there — I found more and more things to be unhappy about.
I still have dysphoria, but it's more like 'oh yeah that's a thing with me' rather than being painful. One of my biggest frustrations has been finding androgynous clothes that fit me; I learned to knit during lockdown so I can make men's style sweaters that look flattering on me rather than a big tent. I also started gardening and get outside with my dog lots. I'm self-conscious about my chest in the locker room and prefer not to change in front of others; I'm thinking of getting a tattoo over my scars — maybe a manta ray below them — because we can't go back, but we can move forward.
I had a weird Pap smear after I stopped testosterone and a scare after coming off T, so it was good to keep an eye on it. I wish I did keyhole instead of bilateral mastectomy, and I wish I didn't take T. I also wish I spoke up more about how I felt and what I wanted sooner.
I had to take a good hard look at the environment I grew up in and realize how much crap there was constantly — I was told in school and at home that girls weren't good at math, that I'd be better off doing domestic chores. It took a lot to acknowledge that society was wrong, not me. I got into reading feminist theory and thinking about how gender is socially constructed.
I never told my parents I detransitioned and I do not plan to — I don't want them in my life for reasons far beyond the gender stuff. My worst experience telling people was family who worried I'll ruin my social life only to transition back. Most people were lovely and supportive; most people who didn't know my situation were perfectly lovely and understanding. I have lots of friends, and I have the same partner, who has been tricky but ultimately supportive — they felt like my gender impacts their identity. I told people closest to me but I don't broadcast it. One time I got asked if I was trans and I said no, and that was the end of it. Not often am I assumed to be trans. I quit my job during the pandemic and got one where I could work remotely; it's been a bit lonely but I feel fortunate.
I don't agree with scare tactics around the trans/detrans debate — that's how we got abstinence-only education. I found the book exploitative on the whole: it explored the most painful parts of our journey and used it as propaganda to scare parents of trans kids. I want being detrans to not be seen as a lie or an attack on the community, and I think we need more honest discourse with empathy on both sides.