被迫以女孩身分生活,直到15歲逃走
男性 · 已去轉變449
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我生來為男,從小被母親——一名共產黨幹部和基督教諾斯底信徒——強迫認同並作為女孩生活,直到我15歲逃跑並停止認同為跨性別女孩。我是生理男性,有一種讓我看起來像女性的疾病和童年手術,如今在約30年針對童年創傷和虐待的治療後自認是男性。我與一名順性別女性結婚,自認是去性別轉換或被迫轉換者,曾遭到LGBT社群以及部分detrans社群的拒絕。我支持有真實性別不安的人,但反對政治/意識形態的跨性別行動主義以及任何將性別認同強加於兒童的做法。
完整故事
I was born male, and from an early age my mother — a communist official in both East and West Germany and a member of a Christian Gnostic commune/cult — forced me to identify and live as a girl, using physical violence when necessary. I never wanted to be anything other than a cis male; the decision to identify as a trans girl was hers, not mine, and she sold it to me and others as what I truly wanted while I was not allowed to say otherwise. Her ideology was a blend of Marxism, absolute idealism, and Gnosticism: she genuinely believed objective physical reality doesn't exist and that if she raised me as a girl, I would become one, and that being transgender was sacred because it 'TRANScended' binary gender. I grew up in that Gnostic commune/cult environment. I also have a certain medical condition and had surgeries as a child which, combined with my upbringing, made it possible for me to pass as fully female even when naked — though I am biologically male. I passed as a girl roughly 30 years ago. I ran away from my mother at age 15, and after that I stopped identifying as a trans girl. I have had surgeries — I told my wife about them before we married, and I am biologically male and now identify as a man. I achieved a high female voice through voice training alone (no surgeries to my voice) and later regained a deep male voice through voice training again, which I am very glad about in hindsight because I avoided irreversible body alterations. I consider whether I count as 'detrans' to be an open question, since I was forced into identifying as trans rather than choosing it myself, but I have posted in detrans communities and consider myself to have gone back to identifying as the gender I was born as. I faced a lot of rejection after announcing I would go back to identifying as my birth gender, and lost many or all friends, as I believe most detransitioners do. I was very trusting and naive about the LGBTQ community, believing they were about tolerance, and was hurt when they made it clear they were not supportive of my decision to affirm the gender identity that aligns with my biological sex — I feel they are supportive of my abusers instead. I experienced the same denial-of-leaving mentality from trans activists that I experienced in cults: they refuse to acknowledge that someone ever was or could leave. I was very trusting and naive as a child, and I had severe psychological trauma and severe abuse in my childhood, which led to very low self-esteem, looking down on myself, and hating myself, which made dating as a man extremely challenging. It took me 30 years of therapy to get to where I am now rather confident and comfortable in my relationships. My mother later refused to see a doctor or take vitally important medicine for a curable illness, insisting she could negate it with her mind; when I told her she was being delusional and needed to see a doctor, she shunned and hated me and claimed her illness was my fault because I refused to affirm her delusions. She has since died — not old and not incurably sick — and I have come to realize she in a passive way ended her own life. The hardest thing for me was realizing it wasn't my fault, but because of her delusions and refusal to get psychological or medical help. I now identify as a man and as a liberal, and I try to keep politics out of trans issues. I am married to a cis woman whom I love; I told her everything about my past and my surgeries right from the start, and her being cool with it told me she was a keeper. Our wedding night went smoothly precisely because of that honesty. I have done many interviews about my childhood, my mother, and the Gnostic cult I grew up in. I am not against children medically transitioning if it is genuinely their own choice, and I have nothing but love, sympathy, respect, and support for people with genuine gender dysphoria — but I am opposed to extremists forcing their children to adopt a gender identity they know isn't right for them, and I am not supportive of trans activists who treat being trans as a political ideology. I have been active in detrans communities for a long time and have pushed back against people telling trans-identified youth to stop being trans, arguing that a person's true gender identity is the one they identify with despite abuse, not because of it. I have also been told by others in the detrans community that I don't belong and am not detrans, and I have at times offered to stop posting in response.