長頭髮,對轉變曾掩蓋了什麼有著強硬看法
男性 · 已放棄245
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我是一名留著長髮的異性戀去過渡或停止的男性,常在去過渡社群中評論。我相信跨性別身份是應對潛在心理健康問題——即強迫症、自閉症和亞斯伯格症、性創傷以及身體畸形或飲食失調——的一種方式,這些問題必須在醫學過渡之前得到治療。我建議人們在改變身體之前先檢查自己的心理健康,去看不專注於性別理論的精神科醫生,我批判網路跨性別社群的脆弱、執念和縱容。我的女朋友患有強迫症,這滋養了我對強迫性思維模式的興趣。
完整故事
I've been active in the detrans community commenting on other people's stories, and I've developed a fairly consistent framework for how I understand why people end up transitioning. I keep coming back to what I see as three underlying commonalities among trans people, sometimes more than one at once: sexual trauma, autism or Asperger's, and body dysmorphia — hating and not being able to identify with your body. I've said publicly that I haven't found an example of anyone who didn't have these things. I also now believe OCD is a major underlying factor; I've told people directly that their stories scream undiagnosed OCD and autism, and that the obsessive thought patterns and social hang-ups trans people describe aren't expressed or even thought about by healthy people.
I've talked about my own life in a few places. I'm a straight man with long hair, and I've been misgendered my whole life because of it. It doesn't bother me — I think people who build an entire personality around something they want written off from science as a 'social construct' have an unhealthy obsession. I've also mentioned that my girlfriend has OCD, and that I often help her recognize behaviors she doesn't even notice herself.
My general advice to anyone questioning their gender is to explore their mental health issues before they make attempts to alter their body and its chemistry, because cosmetics will not fix the underlying issues. I tell people to see a psychiatrist who isn't obsessed with gender theory. I believe detrans people prove that underlying mental health issues need to be treated rather than pushing chemicals on children — I've argued that if detrans people didn't exist, it would justify what I call the 'fake reality,' and that there are probably more detrans people now than any population of trans people before what I've called 'gender theory grooming' came into play.
I'm pretty blunt about the trans community online. I've said trans identity is a cope for other underlying mental health issues, that having rational conversations with mentally unstable people isn't easy, and that the community's feelings are 'incredibly fragile and explosive' — which I've linked to autistic traits. I've told people they have power over their online antagonists because those people are so enveloped in online presence, and I've used harsh language toward people I see as pushing gender ideology, including calling typing-and-gender-theory links 'softcore grooming.' I've also told someone bluntly that there's no world where their vocal cords ever sounded like a man.
On documents and legal protocols, I've defended strict ID rules, arguing that inconsistencies in documents make it easier to commit illicit or terrorist activities, and that procedures and protocols are in place to keep everyone safe — I told someone they were taking it too personally.
Overall, I see myself as someone trying to push back against what I view as enabling rather than helping. I believe recognizing the conditions behind gender distress — OCD, autism, past sexual assault, body dysmorphia and eating disorders — can help people understand why they feel the way they do, and I've encouraged people to read through others' posts here to collect those key pieces of info.