到2022年年中開始質疑一切,告誡他人遠離荷爾蒙
男性 · 已去轉變225
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我是一名去過渡或正在停止的人,到2022年中期一直質疑性別意識形態並警告他人提防倉促的醫學過渡。我逐漸相信性別是生物學事實,而gender無法被證明,我認為跨性別活動空間容易受到灌輸。我不確定自己的感受是真正的焦慮還是對情緒動盪、色情和社交媒體的反應,我敦促在做決定前等到穩定。我強烈警告提防激素和不可逆的改變,強調自然青春期和生育能力的價值。我支持其他正在停止的人,鼓勵他們無視任何把他們推回過渡的人。
完整故事
I came to these communities in June 2022, and looking back at what I was writing then, a lot of it was me working through my own doubts out loud while also trying to help other people who were questioning. I had been around trans activist spaces and I told people directly that the mentality there 'is just straight up vulnerable' — that was my own read on it, and it reflected something I had come to believe from my own experience.
I was skeptical of the mainstream narrative around gender. I wrote that 'Gender is not a provable thing, sex is a biological fact,' and I compared gender-affirming reasoning to 'affirming the stuff someone with schizophrenia claims to see or hear.' I also said 'That's really what makes me consider the indoctrination thing to be true' when discussing trans activism. I watched part of a documentary on the subject and found it 'reasonable spot on,' noting that some of the people interviewed seemed 'strange in behaviour and talking' to the point I thought they might be actors.
On a personal level, I was clearly wrestling with whether my own feelings were real dysphoria or something else. I told someone else — but it read as advice I needed to hear myself — that if you go through puberty into your 30s 'without feeling actual dysphoria that pushes you to transition with no question, i doubt you're trans at all.' I suggested that what I was feeling might be about temperament or wanting to look a certain way rather than being trans, and I warned against 'chemically castrating yourself' to maintain a look. I also flagged pornography and social media as things that could distort body image and emotional state, saying they could 'multiply your emotional trouble that can develope to mental problems not just dysphoria,' and I recommended meditation and processing emotions instead.
I was strongly opposed to medical transition for anyone who wasn't certain, especially regarding puberty and fertility. I laid out what I saw as the stakes: natural puberty would let you either be 'a happy male who had a phase' or transition later 'and be a stronger female,' whereas hormones would leave you 'unable to have children or have sex properly + got weaker and depressed.' I told people their natural puberty and fertility 'are not something you can risk destroying for something you're unsure about yet.'
I also spoke to people who were desisting. I told one person, 'you are not' trans if what they really wanted was to be more feminine, and that liking video games or having so-called masculine hobbies doesn't make someone trans. I said anyone who hated them for desisting was 'just as bad as transphobes' and to stay away from anyone pressuring them back in. I also told someone that 'Who you are is not your gender remember that you will remain you no matter what shape your body takes,' and I hoped they could 'get back whatever you lost from that journey.'
I don't have a full medical timeline in what I wrote here — I didn't spell out dates for when I first felt dysphoria, when I came out, whether I socially transitioned, whether I took hormones or blockers, or whether I had any surgeries. What I do know is that by mid-2022 I was on the questioning/detrans side of these conversations, I was warning others off hormones and off irreversible decisions, and I was framing my own situation as something I was still figuring out — whether it was 'confusion because of what you went through' or something real, as I put it when advising someone to wait until they were stable before deciding how serious they were about transitioning.