二十年的性別不安,沒有過渡
男性 · 已放棄295
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我是一位自我認同為detrans的男性,實際上從未進行轉變,但從約5歲到25歲把自己認同為跨性別者,並接近轉變。在r/asktransgender上的一次負面互動促使我研究批判性觀點後,我不再把自己認同為跨性別者;如今我把轉變視為美容性的,而非真正的性別改變。我仍有性別焦慮,但它已從令人失能的需求減弱為被動的願望,同時我在三十出頭公開以女性化的、性別不順從的男性身分生活。我有中度強迫症,也沒有手術或荷爾蒙病史。我仍批評把轉變作為解決方案,同時努力尊重選擇它的人。
完整故事
I was born male. I first felt that I should be a woman when I was a small child — I've struggled with dysphoria since early elementary school, and I thought of myself as trans from roughly ages 5 to 25. I never actually transitioned, though I came close and seriously considered it for many years; I used to dream about transitioning in high school and say it was the thing that kept me going. I also have moderate OCD.
What changed for me was a specific moment on r/asktransgender. I had commented, diplomatically, that it isn't transphobic for a straight man not to want to date a trans woman because she is trans. The reaction was visceral — I was labeled transphobic — and it confused me, since attraction isn't a rational process. That pushed me to explore the other side of the internet: anti-trans subreddits and literature. I didn't agree with all of it, but I agreed with some of it, and over a couple of days (even hours) my entire viewpoint flipped. I came to believe that transition is essentially 'a game of pretend,' that changing sex is impossible, and that the idea gender is separate from sex is a fantasy that gives people with dysphoria hope and justifies the condition. I described it as breaking free from 'the cult.'
Importantly, this didn't stop the underlying feeling. If I had a 'magic button' to become a woman I would press it in a heartbeat. What changed was that I separated the dysphoria from my personal happiness. I stopped identifying as trans and stopped planning to transition. I reframed myself as 'a guy, maybe a gender non-conforming guy, who wishes he was a woman' rather than 'a woman in a male body,' and I decided to treat gender as just one part of my life — 'a crappy part, but a single part.'
I've thought a lot about what actually drives this for me. I don't have a clear explanation — I never justified my identity through the usual frameworks, I just felt that being the opposite gender was 'right.' I'm 95% sure I was born dysphoric, but I take that to mean 'some wires got crossed,' not that male brains exist in female bodies. I've come to believe a big part of it was that I hated being seen as masculine: socially, personally, and emotionally I've always been a very feminine person, and I felt trapped and unseen, like I was wearing a mask. I also discussed autosexuality and AGP in my own experience, noting that a desire to not be yourself and self-loathing are not typical narcissistic traits, and acknowledging that envy can express itself as misogyny or as desperate overcompensation into being 'one of the good ones.'
The practical work of living with it has been expressing the feminine parts of my personality without swapping my gender identity: I grew my hair out, got new clothes, and removed my internal filters that stopped me acting feminine in public. I talk, look, and behave how I want. I reject labels internally — I don't really consider myself a 'guy' or a woman, but 'a feminine person with a male body,' and I enjoy defying gender norms at every opportunity for the small satisfaction and comfort it brings. I'd say my dysphoria has gone from a crippling need to a passive want, and I only recently passed that threshold of comfort, in my early 30s.
I've never had surgery or hormones, so there are no medical complications or fertility concerns to report. I do not consider myself trans anymore. I hold a critical view of transition as a solution: I believe there is no medical way to change sex, that transition is rooted in cosmetics and social validation, and that even if I passed I'd look in the mirror and see 'a guy pretending to be a girl.' I think HRT and surgery don't address the underlying issue for me. At the same time, I try to be respectful: I have sympathy for trans individuals, I acknowledge transition might be right for some people as a last resort after trying other things like therapy, and I generally won't push my views on someone unless we have a relationship where they'd be receptive. I'm critical of what I see as an 'information war' making transition sound perfect, and I've compared trans-identity reasoning to 'trans-disabled' identity claims, arguing there's nothing special about gender that elevates it above other types of trans. I've also expressed frustration at being told I'm 'in denial' or not really dysphoric when I try to explain how I see myself.