一個從未變性的XXY男性
男性 · 已放棄162
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我去性別轉換了……我從未轉換:我是一名XXY(克萊恩費爾特)男性,自認是detrans社群的靜默同情者而非成員。我在成年時發現了自己的XXY狀態,由醫生從表型上確認但從未做基因檢測,這改善了我的心理健康並減輕了無子女的愧疚。我強烈批評對有性別不安的青少年的青春期阻斷劑和當代性別理論,在學哲學期間我被捲入圍繞這些觀點的爭議。我到19歲前一直被人叫錯性別,我視自己為「只是一個XXY男孩」,而非跨性別或非二元。
完整故事
I was born male, and I have XXY (Klinefelter) syndrome — though I only discovered it well into adulthood. I haven't been officially genetically tested, because that costs nearly $1000 and is hard to get unless a fertility clinic requests it, but a physician confirmed I match the phenotype. The discovery had a very positive effect on my mental health and self-image: I was relieved of lingering guilt for not having given my mom a grandkid, and I could at last explain so many odd quirks of my life in one fell swoop. I check the 'intersex' box on forms when it's available, though I know the XXY community is far from unanimous about wanting to be called intersex — we start out looking just like XY babies, so we and our families don't have to cope with ambiguous genitalia, and most men with XXY discover the condition when their wives aren't getting pregnant, which is a hard enough blow without also being told they're suddenly intersex.
I've never transitioned and don't identify as trans. I described myself as 'only an XXY guy who got misgendered on the regular until I was 19,' and I've joked about whether being XXY makes me non-binary — I said I truly do 'feel XXY in that hip gender identity way' and that it jives with my INFJ personality type, but that was tongue-in-cheek. I also noted that one common XXY trait I invert: many XXY people have trouble with words, although I was very late to begin talking as a child, which is a hallmark. I consider myself a lurking ally to the detrans community rather than a member; when someone suggested intersex people weren't allowed to post, I said I'd rather remain a lurking ally than tell white lies and offered to leave, but I clearly care about the community — 'I love y'all so fucking much.'
I studied philosophy a few years before 2022 and got a lot of hate during the 'awful Hypatia affair' for my views, which seemed to be coming from a cishet white male — I wondered how much credibility my extra chromosome would have gained me. I have a friend who felt betrayed when a GNC lesbian colleague transitioned, and I noted it 'does seem like there's some weird domino effect' of transitions rippling through friend groups.
My views on transition medicine are strongly critical, especially regarding puberty blockers. I wrote that blockers are intended to delay precocious puberty in girls under eight and boys under nine, only for two or three years tops, and that delaying non-precocious puberty all the way up to age 16 is 'incomprehensibly reckless' because off-label prescribing safety can't be inferred to exist. I argued there isn't even evidence that delaying puberty significantly or reliably reduces suicidality in those diagnosed with gender dysphoria, citing STAT News and City Journal pieces. I've also asked what contemporary gender theorists make of the Reimer case.
I don't report any surgeries, hormones, or detransition medical history — I never transitioned. I don't describe mental health diagnoses beyond noting the positive psychological impact of learning about my XXY status. My mom was a fan of someone (a public figure) who transitioned, which I didn't know about. I have no stated regrets about transition because I never underwent one; my main personal concerns are fertility-related (I understood I'm almost certainly shooting blanks) and the guilt I've since been relieved of.