以跨性別身分生活三年半,隨後直面性別焦慮
女性 · 已放棄38
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我是一名完成退跨的女性,曾以跨性別身分生活了大約三年半,之後我決定改為直接面對性別不安。我相信,未被診斷的邊緣型人格障礙與內化的厭女情緒助長了我的跨性別認同。我對青少年中非二元認同的趨勢、以及把性別轉換宣傳成萬能解藥的做法抱持懷疑,同時我仍然相信性別轉換確實幫助了許多真正有性別不安的人。我認同自己是女同志,並表達過為此感到釋然,而不是作為一名男同志。我因自己的觀點遭到反對與被噓,但我依然直言不諱。
完整故事
I've been open about my own history: I thought I was trans for about three and a half years, and I've come to believe that undiagnosed borderline personality disorder was a big part of what drove that. I also think internalized misogyny pushed me toward identifying as trans. I ended up deciding that coping with dysphoria directly was the better route for me rather than continuing down a transition path, and I'm still dealing with that dysphoria day to day. It's a tough life, but I don't expect everyone to end up on the same path I did.
Because of my own experience, I get frustrated when I see people trying to gatekeep transition based on one person's story. At the same time, I'm skeptical of some of the current trends I see online. I've commented that a lot of kids and teens recently have been thinking they're nonbinary because they can't "feel" gender, when really cis people aren't supposed to feel it — you just exist. I've also noted that dyed hair tends to correlate with teenagers trying to look and or stand out, and that teens who will do anything for attention often end up claiming to be nonbinary or trans and faking mental disorders. I try to tell people not to take that kind of observation personally — humans recognize patterns, and dyed hair can be one of them.
I've also pushed back against people who use studies on trans suicide rates to argue that transition doesn't work and should be banned. I've argued that being trans is a lifelong, extremely mentally painful condition, so it's no surprise suicide is more common among trans people, and that every other study shows transition typically does help, even if it doesn't fix everything. I compared it to saying suicide is more common among depressed people, so medication must not work and should be banned. I've said gender dysphoria is a mental illness similar to depression, bipolar, or BPD, and asked what makes it different that people want to ban treatment just because it doesn't work for everyone. I've gotten a lot of downvotes for that stance and have told others to ignore the people fighting — I said I'd take all the downvotes myself.
I've tried to be supportive of people questioning or detransitioning. When one person described detransition hitting them like a truck, I told them it might just be a dysphoria fluctuation and that emotions and dysphoria fluctuate, advising them to wait a few more days before lunging into anything. I admitted I was worried about coming off as insensitive and said I'm not the type to try to convince someone they're trans, but that I'd personally never heard of detransitioners saying it hit them like a truck, which struck me as a red flag since I used to have those experiences too. When they confirmed they were sure, I said I was happy for them and wished them the best.
I've expressed sympathy for men's experiences too, telling one man his story made me think he was "born in the wrong society" and saying how badly society treats men is unfair — adding I'm glad sometimes that I'm a lesbian rather than a gay man, even though I feel terrible saying that. I've also told a trans person that the way they spoke read as feminine but their voice pitch read as gay guy, and suggested working on raising their pitch. I have nothing but respect for some trans people, and I've defended a trans woman's appearance against claims she looked male, saying she looked perfectly male to me and accusing the other person of just hating trans people.