所有故事

從未過渡,卻在 r/detrans 發文

女性 · 已放棄601
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。

在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。

有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。

摘要

我出生時為女性,雖然我從不描述自己接受過醫療跨性別過渡,但2023年初我作為青少年醫療跨性別、青春期阻斷劑和基於肯定式照護的批評者,在r/detrans上大量發文。我有因疏於照顧的父親而遭受童年飢餓、持續性骨骼損傷(凹陷的肋骨、13歲時撕裂的一根肋骨、嘎吱作響的髖關節)、憂鬱症、涉及我的皮膚和鎖骨的自我傷害,以及與復仇念頭交織多年的自殺念頭之病史。我主張將鍛鍊、飲食、緩慢減量荷爾蒙以及重新引入一個人原本的性荷爾蒙作為跨性別過渡的替代方案,並且對跨性別網紅、跨性別者中自閉症/ADHD盛行率的說法,以及我所稱的「跨性別邪教」深表懷疑。在這份文字記錄中,我不聲明任何當前的認同標籤,也不描述個人的去跨性別化。

完整故事

I was born female and grew up in a household where I was neglected by my father — I have said that I "already had starved due to a neglectful father," which left me with lasting skeletal damage: dented ribs, a rib torn away from the ribcage after lifting logs for five hours straight at age 13 when I weighed 40kg, and a crackling hip that has drawn comments from strangers offering me products for bone density. I have described my body type in the past as "gollum asthetics," and I have said that when I was "starving quite literally" I later started growing muscles, felt better, and "got some curves on me now." I have never described undergoing hormones, surgery, or a social transition myself. What I have described is a period of depression and mental health spiraling during which I engaged in self-harm: "When I myself became depressed and mental health spiraled out of control then body mutilation became more common for me (messing with skin or pulling collar bones till they could dislocate)." I have also written about having been "mentally abused to the point Im a human computer of sorts, Im unfeeling after suicidal thoughts wrestled with the idea of revenge for years," adding that you don't see many people going through that "without becoming a serial killer." That is the closest I have come to describing my own mental health history in this transcript. Most of what I posted in early 2023 was commentary rather than personal narrative. I was sharply critical of the medical system's handling of transition: I argued that affirmation-based therapy amounts to "paying an expert to say youre right and not disagree with you," that assessment had shrunk from two years to "two 20 minute sessions," and that doctors who "fuck up the surgery" or therapists who barely challenge a patient's views deserve punishment. I was especially focused on puberty blockers and hormones in children, repeatedly citing claims that Lupron causes extreme bone thinning, scoliosis, osteoporosis, and "chemo brain," and contrasting a claimed 4-year, 11-22ml course for trans children against a 6-month, 3.7-11ml course for cancer patients. I argued that hormones are essential for mineral absorption and bone development, and that "atrophy" — from cancer, radiation, lack of training, lack of hormones — is damaging in ways comparable to radiation. I was skeptical of the idea that gender is distinct from sex, writing that "Gender seems to get mixed up with stereotypes or personality," and I repeatedly characterized transition as a kind of "I'm not like the other girls" phenomenon, especially among girls. I was critical of trans influencers such as Jammie and Noahfinnce, saying they "both seem to follow a trend and seem miserable," and I speculated at length that a large share of trans-identified people are autistic or ADHD and therefore "easy to exploit." I also voiced hostility toward what I called a "trans cult" and argued that becoming TERF-identified is really being "anti-cult or anti-pharma-bucks." I was active in giving advice to people posting about detransition. My standard recommendations were: lower drug intake slowly, exercise, find a doctor you can trust who may recommend reintroducing your original sex hormones, eat balanced healthy meals, stay off the internet for a while, and pick up a hobby such as cooking. I repeatedly pushed physical fitness as an alternative to medical intervention, saying things like "Does anyone offer a gym membership instead of drugs and surgeries?" and suggesting that getting "jack[ed] in the gym" can flatten the chest. I also advised someone considering coming out to just say they are "a tomboy and got way too confused due to stereotypes," arguing that momentary embarrassment is better than holding it in forever. I was suspicious of r/actualdetrans, warning people not to join its Discord servers and characterizing its members as people who blame themselves for abuse by doctors. I was appreciative of the r/detrans moderators, thanking one for their work and asking how someone becomes a mod "with the hole anti-detransness in Reddit." I also expressed a conspiratorial reading of the whole field, tracing it to John Money and describing the situation as a "large scale feminization fetish used on weak willed." Sexually, I mentioned watching trans women's pornography and expressed disgust at what I perceived as very young-looking performers, questioning whether their parents were backing them. I also speculated that some people's desire to transition might be "a fetish? Or some sissy roleplay youre very much into? Or lack of femininity in your life, like a mother figure?" I do not describe a detransition of my own in this transcript, and I do not describe any current identity label. What I do describe is a history of depression, self-harm involving my skin and collar bones, suicidal thoughts, and years of thoughts about revenge, alongside childhood starvation and significant skeletal injuries.