所有故事

作為女孩被霸凌,被激進地推入男性框架

女性 · 已放棄808
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。

在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。

有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。

摘要

我是一名退跨的女同性戀者(ftmtf),曾以社會性跨性別身分生活約四年,並以社會性女性身分生活了兩年。我之所以跨性別,是因為身為一名被其他女性霸凌的自閉症女孩,我內化了厭女並陷入孤立;在意識到自己已被激進化、套入一個刻板化的男性框架之後,我選擇了停止(desist)。退跨以來,我與男跨女跨性別者有過遭受虐待和被操控的經歷,其中包括一段我形容為帶有脅迫性和情感虐待的關係,這讓我在 MtF 面前感到不適,並擔心被推向一個我並不想要的 TERF 立場。我沒有描述荷爾蒙或手術,目前我認同自己是一名退跨的女性,也是一名女同性戀者。

完整故事

I am an autistic woman who identified as trans and lived socially as a man for roughly four years before desisting, and I have now been living socially as a woman for about two years. I am a lesbian. I came to transition because I deeply hated womanhood and being female — I hated how other women treated me as if I were fundamentally different or worse, how women were portrayed in media and film, and how women were referred to in daily life, as if women were meant to be stupid, superficial eye-candy. Growing up as an autistic girl left me isolated from other women; I was ruthlessly bullied by women and had almost exclusively male friends. I now understand my original transition as an attempt to escape womanhood and my perception of what being a woman meant — looked down upon, stupid, ditsy — which I recognize as internalized misogyny. I also recognize that I was slowly radicalized over time toward the furthest end of trans ideology simply because I was surrounded by people who thought that way. Coming out of it, I was terrified that I had lost my identity and who I was as a person in order to force myself into a stereotyped box of a male. I was afraid of black-and-white thinking when I detransitioned — I did not want to end up hating all trans people or over-generalizing them as one monolith. After detransitioning I had a series of negative experiences with male-to-female trans people, both online and in real life. I wrote that I had had "absolutely horrible experiences with every MTF I've ever talked to" online, and that in real life I had been manipulated and abused by MTFs I came in contact with. One relationship was particularly damaging: a person I liked as a friend began identifying as a woman so I would date him, knowing I was a lesbian (I was still struggling with compulsory heterosexuality at the time). Once we started dating he sexualized himself as a woman, dressing in pink and skirts, having me call him a "good girl" and degrade him, and being completely submissive toward me. I felt coerced into this. He then became emotionally abusive — I was responsible for his emotions at all times, I could not have friends because he was jealous of them, he made every moment sexual even as I became repulsed by his "hyper feminine, hyper sexual" persona, and he manipulated me into being okay with him smoking weed with another girl in his basement. Overnight, while we were still dating, he switched back to he/him, began dressing in suits daily, patronized me intellectually, and treated me "like a man would." When I broke up with him he threatened to kill himself if I left. He had been cheating on me with that other woman for months. I later heard he identified as trans again when he got with that woman, who is queer. I believe he only claimed to be trans to get with me and possibly with her. On Reddit I became convinced that autogynephilia is real. I described clicking on profiles whenever I saw creepy comments about women written to sound as if a woman wrote them, and finding self-proclaimed "trans girls" nine times out of ten, sometimes with large public porn libraries sexualizing women. I recounted an incident where a trans woman insisted it was normal for women with large breasts to put cold drinks between their breasts, which many cis women in the comments denied, until the OP deleted the comments and guilt-tripped them. I also expressed discomfort that lesbian and women's subreddits are heavily populated by trans women, and that mental-illness shitposting subs "made for women" seem largely populated by trans women, which I speculated might be a romanticization of women's mental health issues. I wrote a long vent post about feeling increasingly uncomfortable around male-to-female trans people, saying that talking to one feels like talking to "a shabby caricature of a woman" whose personality is formed off stereotypes. I asked how to deal with being uncomfortable with a population that is unavoidable online and increasingly common in person, while explicitly saying I did not want to generalize and wanted tips on how not to. I pushed back against commenters who told me to soften my language, saying I would not censor my feelings in a forum made for being honest about detransition experiences. I acknowledged that most MTFs are probably not creepy, but said my own experiences had all been upsetting or disgusting, making it hard to maintain that belief. I described the polarizing nature of the debate, feeling that trans rhetoric demands word-for-word agreement and that detrans people also contribute by generalizing, with both sides pushing each other toward extremes. I said I have no problem with drag queens or gender non-conforming men, but feel invalidated by people who have no idea what it is like to be a woman coveting the experience, and that it is hard to tell an actual predator from an AGP person without ill intent, so sometimes it feels easier to keep my distance from all of them. I also argued with people insisting gender and sex are the same thing, maintaining that gender is social and sex is biological and that they are not the same word or meaning, and that gender is a socially defined concept varying across cultures. I told someone to do their own reading or attend college. In another thread I defended a woman whose friend mocked her gender expression, saying he would be called transphobe if he did that to a trans person, and suggested cutting him off. I also commented on a photo of someone, noting they had a slight five o'clock shadow but a female body type, and recommending trimming and shaping eyebrows. In another discussion I noted that in online communities overlapping with gnc, autistic, and gay people, there are more ftm people than cis women now, and that the majority are under 18. I do not describe any hormones or surgeries in this transcript. I do not describe my current mental health diagnoses beyond autism.