作為跨性別男性十二年,不用荷爾蒙,也不後悔
女性 · 已放棄78
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我是一名改變主意/中止了性別轉換的女性,認同為跨性別超過12年,但從未進行醫學轉換,主要是因為疑慮和不支持我的父母。我不再相信性別意識形態,現在把我的性別困擾理解為對強制性別角色的厭女社會的反應,而不是不可改變的特質。當我第一次放下「我可以成為男人」的信念時,性別困擾加重並陷入憂鬱,但此後透過誠實的自我反思有所好轉,儘管大多數日子我仍希望自己是男人。我仍在與性別困擾抗爭,也找不到不肯定性別的治療師,這讓我非常孤立和孤單。我不後悔避開了醫學轉換,現在我對把轉換當作他人的解決方案持批判態度。
完整故事
I was born female and I've had gender dysphoria for pretty much my whole life. I identified as trans for over 12 years — roughly from my early twenties until around 2024 — but I never medically transitioned, a combination of my own doubts and living with parents who wouldn't have supported it. During that time I believed I had a male brain in a female body, what the trans community calls 'Truscum'; I didn't buy into sex being a spectrum or nonbinary identities, and I kept those opinions to myself because I knew how dogmatic the trans community could be.
Looking back, I think the main reason I identified as trans was that I wanted to be accepted. I knew I'd never be accepted as a masculine woman by my family or society, so I just wanted to be a man so I could be myself and still be liked and loved. My mom was a feminist, but growing up she still clearly preferred me being feminine, wouldn't allow me to cut my hair short, and pressured me to get married and have babies. It screwed with my head. I never knew any women I could relate to or look up to.
After I accepted that I didn't believe in gender ideology anymore, my dysphoria got worse for a while and I became really depressed. I described it as having believed there was a door I could someday walk through and become a man; then suddenly the door wasn't even there. I felt truly stuck in my own body, more than ever. Over the years since, after unpacking why I have dysphoria and being fully honest with myself, I hate myself a lot less. I still wish I could be a man most days, but now I can see what triggers it — it no longer feels like an immutable part of who I am, more like a reaction to the world around me. I'm no longer triggered simply by someone recognizing that I'm a woman, and I no longer avoid going out or talking to people because of it.
I've slowly been allowing myself to dress and act more like myself again, which is stereotypically masculine. I cut my hair into a short men's cut, wear only men's clothes, don't shave, don't raise my voice to please people, and work out to build muscle. It's depressing to see how differently people treat me — every time I dress a little more feminine, everyone comments and says they hope I dress like that again. I get called gay slurs on the street and people are generally nastier to me; there's a marked difference between wearing a dress and wearing my normal clothes. My girl friends make faces when I say I want to build muscle or buzz my hair. The only friend I had who was a masculine woman is now taking T and planning surgery; I wanted to talk to her about the risks but I know she'd see me as a bigot. A male friend keeps hinting that I'm trans and seemed offended when I told him I'm a woman. I live in a southern nowhere city and feel completely alone here.
I still struggle with dysphoria even though I don't believe in gender ideology anymore. I think I need therapy to truly lessen it, but I can't find a therapist in the US who isn't gender-affirming and also not conservative/religious. The only person I've ever talked to about it is a family member who is empathetic but doesn't understand, and sometimes it makes me feel worse. I feel very isolated and alone. I've asked whether support groups are open to desisted people like me, since I've never medically detransitioned.
I now think dysphoria is very real but caused by outside factors, mainly our misogynistic, gender-role-imposing society. I don't believe being transgender is anything more than an identity. I've told others bluntly that they will never pass and that identifying as a sex you can't achieve is a lot of strife for no clear goal, and that self-acceptance is more solid. I'm a leftist but I don't think consensus among leftists makes something true. I'm an atheist.