留下了雌二醇,放下了身分認同
男性 · 已去轉變213
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我是一名(社會意義上)去轉換的男性,仍在使用雌二醇HRT,因為我更喜歡女性化的身體,目前我認同為男性或中性,而不需要認同為女性。我在2018年前開始轉換,從2018年底到2022年的過程中開始社會性去轉換,到2022年時已在社會意義上完成去轉換,但仍在使用HRT,只有輕微的副作用(疲勞、力量下降)。我強烈拒絕針對成年人的「跨性別邪教/洗腦」敘事,強調個人責任,並且我嚴厲批評那些我認為在挪用去轉換空間、同時醫療去轉換者的經歷被壓制的TERF或右翼和「放棄轉換者」(desister)聲音。在這份紀錄中,我沒有報告自殺意念、自殘或自殺未遂。
完整故事
I was born male and socially transitioned before Caitlyn Jenner had come out, back when the only trans people I saw were the horrific depictions on TV shows like Maury's 'Is it a Man or a Woman?' specials — I barely knew what being trans even was at the time. I transitioned in the first place because I prefer having a feminine body, and estradiol made me more confident and secure in myself; I couldn't care less how others perceive me or how they gender me.
By 2022 I had socially detransitioned for the most part but was still on HRT. I described the process of moving away from the trans community as gradual, running from late 2018 to the present: 'There wasn't a singular moment but the trans community's terrible atmosphere definitely contributed to parts of it. I don't feel it represents me anymore, my interests nor do I have a voice in the community. It's mostly filled with fetishists and wierdos who have co-opted the community for their own benefit.'
Living as male/androgynous presenting again made day-to-day life easier for me: 'Less wierdos starting small chat and no one really pays attention to guys so I can just do my own thing without getting bothered. Also, I don't feel as vulnerable when I present masculine-ish.' On HRT itself I reported no negative effects besides getting tired a bit more easily and some strength loss: 'Cognitively I don't feel any different nor has it affected my mental health.' I acknowledged everyone's body is different and advised talking to a doctor about pausing hormones to see if issues resolve.
I pushed back hard against claims that HRT causes osteoporosis or cardiovascular disease, arguing estrogen reduces cardiovascular risk compared to cis men with adequate T, and that osteoporosis only happens without adequate supply of either hormones or being on puberty blockers. I noted definite risks exist, especially with exogenous testosterone, but felt others were spreading misinformation.
I hold strong views about personal accountability in transition. I rejected the idea that the trans community is a 'cult' that brainwashed people: 'I willingly did this to myself and there definitely was counter arguments all over the place. So this narrative of I didn't know any better, I got tricked into this by the cult is honestly just as bad as blaming someone else for you getting tattoos/plastic surgery.' I believe adults who transitioned medically or socially can't use the cult excuse, though I allow coercion/grooming situations are different. I've been heavily critical of what I see as right-wing/TERF infiltration of detrans spaces, saying 'this place feels like its swarming with TERFs/Right Wingers who pretend to be detrans,' and I've argued that desisters (who haven't medically detransitioned) often have the most extreme views while medically detransitioned people tend to give more grounded, level-headed responses. I've said 'Desisters need to stop talking over medically detransitioned people' and criticized them for taking up space in detrans activism.
I've also criticized conservative and traditionalist forces for forcing gender stereotypes on children, arguing they do far more harm than the occasional leftist non-binary parent. I personally don't believe anyone under 16 should transition. I advocate for psychological assessment before hormones but doubt gatekeeping alone works since people will lie to providers. My general advice to others considering transition: 'Only transition if you want a feminized body regardless if you're cis/trans/pokemon/alien. Otherwise, you're taking a massive risk for little pay off,' and I've warned people who are still unsure to give themselves more time rather than treat it as an experiment.
I've also commented on how GNC/detrans women get misgendered depending on how masculine they appear, and how people who claim to be fine with masculine women will still clock and ridicule them. I've noted that being read as a butch woman in her early-to-mid 20s is one way people perceive me, and I've discussed how confidence and self-assurance matter more than gender expression in how seriously men take each other.