Grew out of teen dysphoria without ever transitioning
男性 · 已放棄286
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我出生時為男性,青少年時期曾患有性別不安,但在真正進行任何醫療跨性別之前,我自願中止了,如今我認同為男性——一個走出性別不安的去跨性別/中止男性。我把自己的進步歸功於找到帶有男性色彩的嗜好和衣著、時間以及自我接納,如今我處於一段戀愛關係中,並擁有支持我的朋友圈。我批評性別意識形態、社會傳染以及對未成年人的肯定性照護,並主張將非肯定性照護作為第一步,在辯論中引用研究和醫學細節。我形容自己在政治上屬於中間派/自由意志主義者,並因這些觀點失去了一些朋友,不過我說從那以後合適的人進入了我的生活。我沒有報告持續的心理健康困擾、對醫療程序的後悔(因為我從未接受過),或自殺念頭。
完整故事
I was born male. I had gender dysphoria as a teenager — I was drawn to feminine things, wanting to have what women had and to be exactly like them, and I wanted to look similar to a woman while knowing I would never be one. I desisted on my own accord before I ever started a medical transition, and I describe myself as one of the roughly 84–85% who had dysphoria and grew out of it as I matured. The process of accepting myself took several years.
What helped me was finding things I actually enjoyed doing and wearing that guys did. I liked suits and Gothic clothing for guys; my friends were goths, punk, and emo, so I wore suits, dress clothes, and black clothes now and then. I played video games, took up programming as a hobby, and fished and hunted with my dad, which I enjoyed. I also developed a practice of catching myself thinking negatively and changing the topic, complimenting myself once in a while, fixing my hair without nitpicking mirrors, and moving on to the next task, while building an idea of what kind of guy I wanted to be and what life I wanted in the future — goals.
I told my girlfriend (now referred to as 'my girl') that I had gender dysphoria as a teen, and mentioned the various variables that affect people with identity issues, such as ADHD and body dysmorphia. I advised someone else in a similar position that they could either tell a partner or, if they no longer identify that way and don't plan to in the future, simply not mention it. I also suggested that if they do tell, they explain how they improved their environment, stopped talking to people who were 'more culty,' and like where they're at in life.
I lost friends over my views. I ignored those who left; they vetted themselves out and improved my life by no longer taking time I could spend with other friends. The same kind of people behaved the same way toward me. Currently most of my friends aren't on that side of the political aisle and don't give me trouble — they've been quite welcoming. I believe the right people enter your life over time. I don't think you can really call someone a friend if you have to lie about who you are and manage a facade so they stay.
I'm blunt and don't shy away from using actual wording. I cite research papers, medications and their other uses (like sterilizing sex offenders), what the surgeries look like and what they do to someone's life, including things like 'opening the wound daily/few times a week' and how painful that is. I ask people how much they know about how data was collected, the number of participants, and point out where researchers deviated from proper methods. I also bring up what John Money did to push the ideology and what he did to the boys. I've heard activists say things about medications that turned out to be wrong — I looked at the actual research and medicine websites, showed my friends, and they didn't believe me until I showed them the actual medicine websites, then tried to justify it anyway.
I avoid the term 'trans' because it lumps together people with dysphoria, euphoria, body dysmorphia, ADHD, and other conditions that require different forms of care under one umbrella, with conversion tending to be the end goal. I believe most individuals do not need affirming therapy; it used to be reserved for only those with extreme dysphoria, while moderate and mild cases were given other care such as aiding in body acceptance and coping/regulation skills — non-affirming care — before moving to the next step if needed (for example, a breast reduction instead of complete removal for someone with body dysmorphia). I think non-affirming care is a good first step: it wouldn't start with puberty blockers or cross-sex hormones, might not suggest social transitioning (which can cause abrasion in social life and work), and would instead identify underlying issues like anxiety, past trauma, abuse, ADHD, eating disorders, and environment problems. Sometimes those causes exist; sometimes it's just dysphoria, and clinicians should be able to identify which. I acknowledge care takes time — sometimes years — and that withholding information can slow the process and lead to wrong solutions.
I advise waiting until puberty is over before doing meds, saying there is no such thing as 'pausing' puberty, that side effects from those meds are really bad and sometimes you'll be on meds till the day you die, and that there isn't enough scientific data — 'this new generation are the test subjects.' I also try not to get caught up in LGBT activism, warning that such groups can be very supportive but also very vindictive, and to research both sides rather than live in an echo chamber.
I've discussed how some countries in the EU after the Cass Review basically stopped certain hormones and blockers to minors, and I've said the EU closed gender clinics for these reasons while we haven't because of too many activists who don't listen to data. I've also commented on a kid apparently taking hormones without parental consent, saying that's more concerning, and that people should talk to a doctor for a proper prescription rather than listening to randos, since dosages that are too high too fast can cause problems.
I've discussed surgical details, noting they take skin from an arm or leg for the surgery and that the skin doesn't stop its normal functions. I've also given practical advice about body hair — safety razors, foil electric shavers, hair remover, wax, laser hair removal, or shaving less often.
I hold a traditional view of sex and gender: for centuries gender and sex were the same, and pronouns were associated with sex, not 'gender'; the change came post-WWII with what I call 'gender ideology.' I define a woman as an adult female human and a female as, per biology, an individual whose reproductive system is designed to make ova. I say I'm a guy because I'm a biological male, and outside that I don't care how others classify things. I believe the ideology further enforces gender roles while masking and attempting to erase feminine men, tomboys, masculine women, and the roles both sexes have. I've said I had dysphoria and was drawn to feminine things — wanting to have what women did and be exactly like them.
I've argued that women are more social and more influenced by those around them, which is why trends like cutting, split personality disorder, and eating problems come in waves and affect them more — comparing it to DARE programs where kids started cutting or self-inducing vomiting after being taught about it, while schools without those programs didn't have the same problems. I've said social contagion, social media, and friend groups play a large role, and that many kids aren't raised affirming their own sex (e.g., a woman trash-talking men around a little boy). I've also said historically teenage boys were the majority with gender dysphoria by over 90%, and that the uptake in girls and women claiming to be trans without dysphoria suggests conflation of body dysmorphia or sexual issues with being trans.
On politics, I've said I'm more central/libertarian and get called a far-right extremist just for saying I support the US Constitution and Bill of Rights. I've suggested being active in the community — school board meetings, emailing politicians, pushing legislation to protect kids — while noting such things take years. I've made a joke about supporting eugenics that few people understand. On makeup, I've argued the patriarchy has little to do with it and that women enforce beauty standards on each other as a form of competition. I've also discussed the historical Catholic Church's contributions to science and that science is meant to be challenged.
I don't describe any surgeries, hormones, or puberty blockers of my own — I desisted before starting a medical transition. I don't describe any specific mental health diagnoses beyond gender dysphoria as a teen. I don't describe suicidal ideation, self-harm, or suicide attempts.