性別不循規,但不把它醫療化
女性 · 已放棄272
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我是一名去轉型女性,從幼年起就不符合自己的性別角色,但我本人從未接受過荷爾蒙或手術。我現在強烈反對青春期阻斷劑和對未成年人的肯定性醫療照護,警告它們不可逆轉且有損生育能力,並且對跨性別青少年的自殺統計數據持懷疑態度。我建議任何對轉型不確定的人先等待而非行動,說與其被閹割,我寧願把那問題留在心底活著。我沒有描述過任何個人醫療干預、診斷或正式的去轉型過程。
完整故事
I was born female. From around age 4 I wore really short hair and dressed in boy's clothes — my mom always called me "my little boy." Around age 8–10 I really wished I had a penis, but only because I wanted to know what it was like to pee standing; I thought being physically a girl was impractical and inconvenient. Growing up I enjoyed wearing suits and ties with my hair slicked back, and other times a sexy dress and red lipstick — it felt like being a chameleon, enjoying myself and my mood without ever having to question whether I was a woman or a man.
Nowadays I feel like we are pressured to put ourselves in a box with a label in order to belong or be at peace with ourselves. I look at models who look one way one day and another way the next — it is just an act, but the sex remains the same no matter what.
I have become strongly critical of medical transition, especially for minors. I argue that puberty blockers are not reversible, pointing to WPATH's own Standards of Care (pages 50–51), and I say we should wait for evidence that they are in fact reversible. I note that Sweden, which I describe as a leading country in providing medical care for transgender people, is putting the brakes on treatment for trans minors. I acknowledge that duration matters — months versus one day makes a difference — but I insist that the fertility of those people is at risk regardless. I have also urged people not to go ahead with medical steps if they are feeling unsure: "Don't do it! Especially if you are feeling unsure. There is nothing wrong with waiting a bit longer or not doing it at all," and I have linked others to a letter a detransitioner sent to their practitioner. I said I would rather keep the question of my identity in the back of my mind than be castrated.
I am skeptical of widely cited suicide statistics among trans youth, saying many of those claims come from one self-reported study (conducted by The Trevor Project, which I consider extremely biased) and have not been backed up by medical or police records of attempted suicides. I argue such studies must be conducted among LGBTQ and general populations side by side so the data can be compared. I also say that among minors affirmative care is "a big failure" because mental health does not improve, which is why Sweden is cancelling affirmative care for minors.
I have not described any hormones, surgeries, therapy, or a formal detransition process for myself in these posts, nor any diagnoses, trauma, or family rejection. My contribution to this community has been largely argumentative and cautionary — pushing back on claims about puberty blocker reversibility, on suicide data, and on rushing into medical steps, while sharing my own childhood gender-nonconformity as an example that did not require a label or a medical pathway.