一年批判性別意識形態——卻沒有自己的時間軸
女性 · 已去轉變130
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我是一名住在紐約的去轉換者,用了一年多時間批判性地發帖談論性別意識形態、青春期阻斷劑、荷爾蒙和轉換手術,現在按自己的生理性別認定自己。我從未在這些帖子中披露自己的轉換時間線,但我一貫主張,性別焦慮是被焦慮、抑鬱和意識形態影響放大的不適,而非與生俱來的身份。2025年6月,我發布了一個數據收集帖,徵求關於睾酮、阻斷劑和手術造成傷害的證詞,我並推動醫生的法律責任以及諸如HHS Protect Kids倡議之類的政策變革。我在這份記錄中沒有描述自殺意念、自我傷害或自殺未遂。我鼓勵其他去轉換者和有疑慮的人與家人重新建立聯繫、培養生活技能、實踐對自己生理身體的徹底自我接納,並成為榜樣。
完整故事
I have been active in detrans spaces since at least April 2024, and most of what I have posted has been about pushing back against what I see as gender ideology, collecting accounts of medical harm, and encouraging other people who are questioning or detransitioning. I do not think I have ever laid out my own full transition timeline in these posts, so I will just tell you what I actually said.
Early on I was arguing with people about the evidence base for transition medicine. In April 2024 I challenged someone to show me what page of a source showed that puberty blockers or hormones reduce suicide risk, because I did not believe such evidence existed. Around the same time I was asking another person detailed questions about how they concluded that pornography had made them a lesbian or trans — what kind of pornography, media or real or anime, whether they had been attracted to the opposite sex before that exposure, whether a therapist helped them make the connection, and what made them interested in the opposite sex again. Those questions reflect how I think about the causes of gender dysphoria and same-sex attraction: I treat them as products of external influence rather than something innate.
By late April 2024 I was writing about transition content online as propaganda, saying it deliberately hides harms: "Fact they don't push the harms because it would scare them away .. it's made to look like a better happier life … but ignores facts of one video post of someone acting happy doesn't show the misery they live." I wanted surgical outcomes shown openly, including what I called damage done to kids and adults. In May 2024 I posted looking for friends in New York, which is the only direct glimpse I gave of my own life situation — I was in New York and apparently looking for community.
In June 2024 I got into a stretch of more heated commentary. I accused gender ideology of pushing "tons of lies," grooming and brainwashing children, and telling them to keep secrets from their parents. I said I had pictures of surgical harm and described them as horrific, and I proposed making a list of names or websites that had influenced people into transition. I also wrote a long, encouraging reply to someone presenting as feminine again, arguing that there is not one way to be feminine and pushing "Radical self acceptance and self love not self hating," appreciating your biological body, birth-given name and sex, and using exercise and dance for endorphins. I said I had found documentation of harm online but that it was hard to find because people are ashamed or because the medical industry would not document something that hurts its business. I framed gender affirming care as a marketing term designed to hide physical, mental and emotional harm. I also worried that children cannot evaluate the truth because they are taught that anyone telling the truth is hateful and transphobic. I suggested that biological males and females should adopt the same tactics as the other side, and I described the other side as hateful toward biological facts, male and female people, parents, families, language, religion, gays, lesbians and bisexuals. I struggled with the platform itself, saying repeatedly that I did not know how to share things. I also gave advice to someone who said they had no friends, telling them to spend time with family, take up hobbies, learn skills, and use those as ways to meet people.
In June 2024 I made my first post, titled "DeTransitioners and families UNITE," score 22. It urged people to contact Trump on all his social media accounts and inform him about what I called gender lies and misinformation, the shutdown of the Tavistock clinic, the harms of puberty blockers, the claim that puberty blockers are not FDA approved, doctors receiving kickbacks, censorship, the WPATH files, the "Dr Hillary case review," changes of language used to insult others, female erasure, and the brainwashing and grooming of young people. I called for the whole system to be shut down completely and for biological truth to be re-taught to people caught up in the ideology.
Through 2025 I kept up the same themes. In January 2025 I talked about propaganda as an agenda to censor free speech and referenced the Twitter files and Mark Zuckerberg being forced to censor people. I asked someone if they had written a book, and asked to see another person's progress. I advised someone to find good role models, learn life and social skills, appreciate themselves, help other people who think they are trans, and become a role model themselves. In February 2025 I asked where the study was that showed WPATH suppressing information, which suggests I was still skeptical of claims in both directions and wanted sourcing.
In June 2025 I was very active. I asked whether there were studies showing a particular condition as a side effect, and then made the general point that messing with hormones or drugs alters the body and that is why they are called side effects. I urged people to spread awareness on social media "at all costs." I gave a long, highly upvoted (score 23) congratulatory reply to someone whose partner had apparently become pregnant after detransitioning, praising the partner for thinking critically rather than being influenced by ideology, for feeling like a mother rather than a birthing person, and for not focusing on loss or past trauma, which I framed as avoiding intergenerational trauma. I told someone who was scared that fear is a natural response mixed with anxiety and that they would heal with the realization of gender dysphoria, which I redefined as "gender discomfort with highly anxious and depressed people" plus ideological confusion. I advised them to enjoy their natural body, questioned the logic of affirming other body parts to claim a gender, and warned them to be careful about which family members they told — specifically to speak to people who had wanted to tell them something originally but whom the ideology had encouraged them not to listen to or cut off. I told them to be positive as a first step to self love and courage.
I also told someone to list everything they were afraid of, saying the only way over fear is through it, and contrasted the two paths as being yourself biologically with new opportunities versus being trans with a limited dating pool, surgical harms, stress and medication side effects. I brought up the possibility of suing doctors, referencing an HHS letter and saying doctors who pushed ideology for profit might lose legal protection. I asked someone how they had "almost die[d]," which suggests I was reading accounts of serious medical events, though I did not describe one of my own.
On June 26, 2025 I made my second post, score 17: "List of side effects and harm from testosterone / blockers / surgery…Please comment only if harmed …data collection!!" I framed it as data collection and repeatedly asked detrans, trans and questioning people to comment if they had side effects or harms. I was frustrated that it got views but no comments. Around that post I linked to hhs.gov/protect-kids, an HHSGov tweet, and a page from Representative Greene's office, and I pasted a long summary of the "Protect Children's Innocence Act 2025," including age verification requirements for websites, liability provisions, and the point that some state laws allow malpractice claims against physicians for up to 25 years after a child turns 18 with minimum damages for harm from transgender medical interventions.
What I regret, as far as I have expressed it, is not my own body or surgeries in these posts — I never described those — but rather the whole framework of gender ideology and the medical system built around it. My intensity has been fairly steady across the year-plus of posting, and it has been directed outward: toward policy, toward other people's stories, and toward building a record of harm. I have not described my current identity explicitly in these posts, but everything I write assumes I am a detransitioned or desisted person who has returned to identifying with my biological sex and who wants the same for others.