29歲使用雌激素,六個月的恐慌——以及一位說繼續下去的治療師
男性 · 已去轉變456
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我是一位detrans女性……不——我是一位出生為男性的detrans者,曾有一段時間以女性身分生活;detrans之後,如今我對作為男性的性別感到可以接受。我從29歲起使用雌激素約五到六個月,出現了焦慮、驚恐發作、自殺念頭和失業,並在反向性別焦慮讓我厭惡胸部和脂肪變化後停止。我相信我的性別焦慮根源在於自體女性戀,且身為跨性別者是一種精神疾病;我說SSRI帶走了我的性別焦慮,把我帶回了轉變前的自己。我後悔荷爾蒙帶來的時間與身體變化,並批評那位鼓勵我繼續而不是幫我停止的治療師。我仍在detrans社群中活躍,提供建議並批評肯定性治療。
完整故事
I am a person who was born male and who went through a short medical transition in my late twenties, then detransitioned, and I have spent the years since then trying to make sense of what happened and what I actually want.
I started hormones at age 29, having just turned 30 around the time I first posted about wanting to stop after about a month and a half. Very early on, within the first weeks and months of HRT, I developed what I described as an anxiety disorder, panic attacks, and suicidal ideation. I also lost my job and spent about a month jobless without insurance. I decided to stop hormones, and I said that all of those problems went away once I quit. After being about three months hormone-free, I reported that dysphoria had returned and that I was back at square one, unsure whether to go back on hormones or find an alternative and a different therapist, because my therapist at the time thought I was making the wrong choice by not continuing.
In total I was on HRT for about five to six months. During that time my body did change — I developed breasts and fat on my thighs and my bottom — and then I started experiencing what I called reverse dysphoria, where I began hating those very changes. That reverse dysphoria is what drove me to stop transitioning. It was a confusing period: I described a tug of war lasting for hours between my male self and my female self, regretting detransition while also knowing that transitioning had brought me a lot of mental problems. I called it going back to the abyss of transitioning and said I knew it was not healthy or a good idea.
A big part of my story is that I came to believe the autogynephilia explanation applied to me. I wrote that I get turned on by the idea of a female body so much that I desire to have one, and that being aroused by the wanting of a female body was one thing that always made me question whether I was truly transgender. I said that the more cases I saw, the more I believed in the autogynophilia hypothesis, and that it happened to me just a few months before I stopped HRT.
I also had a significant experience with a psychologist I hired specifically to help me stop the trans feelings and be fine with being male. Instead, she validated and encouraged me being trans, told me to continue hormones and participate in women's activities, and guilt-tripped me about detransitioning. I felt I had fallen for it. I later wrote about this publicly, arguing that therapists sometimes let personal beliefs and political views interfere with their work and that when that happens it is a clear sign to find another provider. I believe that therapists being affirming in this way hinders actual help for people who want to detransition.
Recovery physically took time: I said it took me about a year to recover to pre-HRT times after five months of use. I have given advice to others about checking whether testes are still working, about testosterone therapy or drugs to restart them, about fat redistribution returning over time depending on age, and about breast removal surgery being available cheaply in Mexico. I also suggested going out of the country for care, saying there is more than just the U.S.
Over time my views hardened. I wrote that estrogen made me lose myself, claiming that while on it I went from being cool around people with different opinions to becoming what I described in crude political terms as a hardcore leftist trans feminist, and I said I did not know what I was thinking. I described estrogen as having made me insane. More recently, in early 2024, I said I think being trans is a mental illness, and that I got on SSRIs and they took away my gender dysphoria, leaving me feeling like myself from before transition and comfortable being a guy. I have recommended SSRIs to others, saying they worked for me, and I confirmed I feel okay with my gender now.
Throughout, I have been active in detransition communities, sharing my experience, offering medical and practical advice, and critiquing the therapy model I went through. I have been supportive of other people who want to stop hormones or detransition.