歌唱的聲音是唯一至今仍令她悲傷的失去
女性 · 已去轉變首次性別焦慮 5 → 過渡 18 → 去過渡 21674
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我是一名去過渡的女性,同時也認同自己是酷兒和非二元,使用they/she人稱代詞和我選定的男性名字。我11歲就知道自己是跨性別者,15歲出櫃,18歲起使用低劑量睪固酮約2年,並在21至22歲左右因注射併發症以及意識到我想要的某些特質其實與性別無關而驟然停用。我被診斷患有雙相1型(使用睪固酮之前)和「安靜型」邊緣型人格障礙(使用睪固酮期間);自三年多前停用睪固酮以來,我再沒有情緒發作,邊緣型人格症狀也大多消退,部分歸功於我從12歲起接受的每週創傷治療。我並不後悔把過渡當作人生的一個篇章,儘管失去歌唱嗓音仍是唯一讓我真正悲傷的事;身體上月經恢復了,髮際線和面部脂肪也恢復了,我幾乎總被當作女性。我強烈支持等到25歲再過渡,反對右翼挪用去過渡的故事,並主張跨性別與去過渡社群之間團結而非苦澀。
完整故事
I was born female and grew up in a household I now describe as having harsh, authoritarian, shame-based parenting. I'm the eldest daughter, and I was diagnosed with ADHD early in childhood. I have memories from around age 5 of absorbing the belief that "being a woman is gross and painful," and as a young child I carried a vivid, irrational suspicion that something was wrong and disgusting about my body — I even believed for a while there might be a colony of spiders living inside me, a thought I held until about age 10. I felt nauseous seeing myself in a bikini and had heart-pounding anxiety in school gym locker rooms. My parents were highly unsupportive of my visible gender non-conformity even before I told them anything. I was in weekly therapy essentially continuously from age 12 onward.
I knew I was trans at 11 and came out to my immediate friend group in high school as FTM at 15. Coming out actually helped me get over a brief period of anorexia — I think it was a body-control thing, and being acknowledged as trans reduced my preoccupation with food. I also had a brief period where I asked my parents to call me by a nickname of my birth name, and they reacted with yelling and accusations that I was trying to distance myself from the family, which I now recognize as emotional abuse. I bound my chest 8 hours a day every school day through high school and some of university — about 6 years total — using binders (not ace bandages). I was a singer in high school choir with full lung capacity.
I started testosterone at age 18, on the lowest injectable dose, for about 2 years. My stated reasons were physical and social dysphoria — I was viscerally repulsed by my body — but also wanting to prove myself to my parents, to permanently break the mould they had cast me in as the "fragile neurodivergent child," and to embody the masculine traits I associated with capability, intelligence and independence. I also think there was an element of wanting to be attractive, complicated by childhood shame about wanting to be beautiful (being scolded for asking to buy makeup, told mirror-gazing was vain, watching my mother bleach my upper lip). I thought I was craving my parents seeing me as a strong, capable young man.
On T I experienced emotional numbness, which I described as useful for focus, but also rapid mood cycles and more extreme psychotic symptoms — hallucinations and unshakable delusions. I had been diagnosed with bipolar type 1 before T; I was later diagnosed with borderline personality disorder (quiet type) while on T. I also developed injection problems: I suspect I pierced a nerve in my left leg with an intramuscular shot, my right thigh became firm to the touch from poor absorption, and my stomach sub-Q sites became itchy and red for hours or days. I used Vagifem insertables for dryness while on T, prescribed by my doctor for comfort during sex with male partners, about twice a week.
Around age 21 I began realizing I had more femininity in me. The things I actually wanted — being seen as capable, intelligent, trustworthy, connected to my parents — were not actually gendered. I stopped T cold turkey after about a month of inconsistent, self-directed "skipping" doses behind my provider's back; my trans provider told me she would have recommended exactly that. I was about 21-22 when I stopped. The first 2-3 months off T were rough: menopause-like symptoms, poor temperature regulation, sleepiness, muscle pain from atrophy, worse period cramps, hot flashes and shivering. These tapered off by months 3-4 and stopped entirely around month 7 when my period became regular. My period came back loud and strong about 3 months after stopping. My acne got worse off T than on T — I eventually cut out almost all eggs and cystic acne disappeared within a week; I still deal with cycle-related acne and post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation. My facial cheeks only started filling out around 1.5 years off T. My hairline has been filling back in. I've been in trauma therapy that has been profoundly helpful, involving guided visualizations, inner-child work, and parts work; I also did DBT and cognitive restructuring. I've been in weekly therapy for about half my life.
I have not had a bipolar mood episode since stopping T — now over 3 years, my longest remission ever. My BPD symptoms have diminished significantly; most people in my life don't know about these diagnoses. I did experience sexual assault later in life while already on T, and I'm still rebuilding from it.
On family: my household was traumatic growing up, and I saw my parents as antagonists through my teen years. When I moved out, they did their own processing and accepted me as their FTM son, and our relationship began healing. About a year later I detransitioned, and because they had already done so much internal work, they took the news well — their acceptance of my trans identity extended to accepting all of who I am. Today I have a very close relationship with them and with my younger brother.
Sexuality: I was deeply shamed for a budding interest in women as a young person, and I still sometimes despair that I may never have a lesbian girlfriend, though I recognize that as anxiety. I've had relationships with male partners. I currently have a very dominant, very masculine male partner who knows my full past and welcomes my full expression, including evenings where I take on the more masculine role.
On regret: I don't frame my story as a tragedy. I don't regret the years I spent living as a guy — it taught me what I was desperately curious about. I describe detransition as one chapter in my life story. The one thing that causes me genuine grief is my singing voice; I was a lifelong singer and contralto, and the psychological pain around singing and humming is "the only piece of me that makes me feel true grief." I'm still processing that in therapy. Voice training has helped enormously — I use the Vocal Image app, do morning warm-ups, and can speak all day in an elevated pitch; I'm gendered as female about 95% of the time and nonbinary about 5% of the time in daily life, and I passed as female 100% of the time during a months-long trip to Europe. I've chosen not to pursue voice feminization surgery because I want to preserve my singing range.
Current identity: I identify as a detransgender, queer, nonbinary person who is comfortable with my female sex and generally presents femininely. I use they/she pronouns and still use my chosen (masculine) name because I like how it fits my androgyny. I describe my gender journey as an expanding window: as a teen I could only see 85% masc/15% fem; now I see myself as containing multitudes. I'm 24, a scientist heading into a pediatric field, and about 2.5-3 years off T.
Attitudes toward transition for others: I support gender exploration and believe people should be encouraged to wait until 25 before medically transitioning, because gender is fluid across the lifetime. I strongly oppose right-wing co-optation of detrans stories (Chloe Cole, Megyn Kelly appearances) and refuse to align with conservatives who I believe want to use detrans people as political props against queer people broadly. I'm critical of TERFs. I believe dysphoria can be resolved without medical transition and that dysphoria has been pathologized unnecessarily. I advocate for solidarity between trans and detrans communities, and I actively push back against bitterness and transphobia in detrans spaces. I have not done formal activism, but I post extensively online offering advice, and I've shared resources (a self-love/dysphoria-reduction guide, podcast recommendations, therapist and clinic recommendations via DM). I advise young detrans people against becoming public media figures. I also briefly worked in news media and left because I found it "slimy."
Current quality of life: I'm happy, healthy, at peace with my body, and in the acceptance stage of grief around detransition. I don't think about gender daily. I do yoga, Pilates, biking, skating, dancing, self-defense, flow arts, kayaking, and rock climbing. I've built a skincare routine, learned makeup (my eyeliner wing is muscle memory), wax/sugar my legs and upper lip, thrift my clothes based on quality rather than trends, and track my period with the Stardust app. I feel close to my family and to my younger brother.