新冠時期的 they/them,然後悄然放棄
女性 · 已放棄409
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我以 Tomboy 的身分長大,在長期在線的疫情期間採用了「非二元」和they/she代詞,到2023年我在社會層面去跨性別化——試圖擺脫they/them,同時擔心會被「取消」,尤其是在我工作的藝術圈子裡。我小時候從未覺得自己是男孩;我說因為LGBT媒體讓我開始質疑性別,而我現在反對給兒童使用青春期阻斷劑,並將其框定為保護年幼的自己。我在身體中慢慢變得更自在,並相信耐心而非期待快速解決方案。我發聲主要是為了幫助那些曾像我一樣的孩子,儘管在我的非二元室友和同齡人面前我保持沉默。我是一名去跨性別化/放棄(desisted)的女性,不再使用they/them代詞。
完整故事
I grew up as a tomboy and was bullied by girls, and I wanted nothing to do with them. I never thought I was a guy growing up — it was only after consuming LGBTQ media during the COVID years, when I was chronically online, that I started questioning gender. I picked up the term "non-binary" and used they/she pronouns; I never called myself trans, though my ex did, saying he "doesn't fit into the assigned gender." I never actually asked people to use they/them, but it was somehow implied in my speech.
By early 2023 I was trying to get off what I called the "they/them bullshit boat," and the social side of detransition was harder than I expected. Older people made fun of me for having once used they/them pronouns, and I couldn't say anything to people my age because I had a crippling fear of being cancelled. I also lived with a non-binary roommate and would rather keep my mouth shut than make the living situation hostile. I'm a shy person and don't really know how to stand up for myself.
I work in the arts, where a lot of people are trans — some fully through HRT and passing — and I felt that saying any of this would make people think I'm transphobic. Pronoun introductions were a particular flashpoint: whenever I was asked to state my pronouns, my brain went into full panic, torn between fitting in by saying "they" like everyone else and getting off the they/she train. I hoped they would just stop asking. One of the sports teams I played on made it clear that stating pronouns should always be optional, and I thought that should be the standard — let others do what they want, but leave me out of it.
After watching creators like Blaire White, Arielle Scarcella and Buck Angel, I became against puberty blockers, framing it as fighting for my younger self: if someone had told me I could be a guy when I was little, I would have said "fuck yeah." My ex and my roommate pushed back, my roommate arguing that "a lot of kids knew when they were young." I countered that I never thought I was a guy as a child and that rising trans rates come from kids being told medically altering their body is okay. I said I was glad I didn't grow up in this day and age, not knowing what I might have done to my body.
I was slowly getting more and more comfortable in my body — "it just takes time" — and I wanted to be patient rather than expect instant solutions. I mostly spoke up on this issue to help people who were just like me when I was younger. I also commented that the cheering narrative around transition is part of the problem, praising people so much that you have to wonder whether they are actually trans or just crave attention, and I said kids need structure and shouldn't be raised as non-binary. At one point I wrote that being able to see this clearly was "probably enough to fuel my will to live."