所有故事

一個走出了這段經歷的男孩子氣女生——卻仍然直言不諱

女性 · 已放棄226
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。

在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。

有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。

摘要

我從未自認是跨性別者或去性別轉換;我是一名在早年青少年時期非常性別不循規蹈矩的女性,透過成長並找到穿著舒適的衣服來處理內化的厭女。現在我在去性別轉換的空間裡寫作,提供建議,警告睾酮和子宮切除術的醫療風險,並抵制我所看到的對跨性別認同不加批判的網路文化。我相信人格與性別分離,與一個梗共情並不能勝過生物學現實,同時我支持人們的自主和安全。我自己的荷爾蒙、手術或性別不適未被描述。

完整故事

I have never identified as trans or detransitioned — I've said so plainly when people asked — but I've spent a lot of time in these spaces offering a perspective shaped by my own teenage years. When I was a younger teen, I was very gender non-conforming, long before trans identities were a widespread topic. I'd internalised a lot of toxic misogynistic attitudes, so I recoiled at anything even vaguely "girly": I refused to wear fabrics that felt soft or silky, and I only wore big shapeless shirts that hid my shape. Getting past that was mostly just growing up, I think. I realised I was making myself miserable for no good reason — that long hair was actually far less effort than short, that scratchy jumpers were stupid when I could wear things that felt nice. I found another aesthetic, and after a few years of wearing clothes that felt good and fit better, I felt so much more comfortable in my own body. I can still dress like a "homeless lumberjack" when I want to, but it's not the only option I allow myself. I've never had dysphoria, hormones or surgery myself, so my contributions are mostly advice and warnings to people who are weighing transition. When someone asked about wearing whatever clothes they liked, I said plainly: "Wear whatever you like. It doesn't have to be an identity crisis, it's just clothes." When someone described being "disgusted" with aspects of being female, I read it as deep-seated internalised misogyny and suggested they needed a better therapist who wouldn't validate hatred of women — I told them to picture an incel saying the same thing to get some perspective. I've made the same point about "not like the other girls" being essentially the definition of internalised misogyny, and about categorising interests as "women things" rather than as the traits of a person with a different personality. On medical questions I've been cautious and research-oriented. I've pointed people toward accounts of severe pain at orgasm from testosterone and atrophy of reproductive organs, and I've warned that a hysterectomy is major internal surgery with dangers of its own — a friend of mine almost died when the surgeon perforated her bowel and she still suffers chronic pain likely for the rest of her life. When someone was facing or recovering from a mastectomy, I tried to put it in perspective: plenty of women have mastectomies for legitimate medical reasons, it sucks but it isn't the end of the world, and having a flat chest doesn't make you any less of a woman than, say, Angelina Jolie. I'm sceptical of online trans-identification culture. I've described "egg" videos as horror shows full of Barnum statements that mysteriously seem personal and appropriate, much like horoscopes, and compared the recruitment dynamic to Scientology. My position, which I've stated directly, is: "Relating to a meme does not trump biological reality. Your body is you. Your personality is distinct from your sex." I've also been blunt with people about dodgy counsellors — one sounded so bad I said it was immediate licence-revoking level dodgy. On social transition and coming out, I've tried to defuse the fear. I said that young people are ALL confused about their identities in similar ways and that it's part of growing up. I've told people that if my non-binary colleague announced they were presenting as female, everyone would just say "oh cool" and think no more of it — people might get the name or pronouns wrong out of habit, but these things look much bigger on the inside than they are, and in reality nobody cares that much, they just want to be polite. I was glad when someone said they got out without harming themselves. Overall I'm supportive of people's autonomy but critical of uncritical affirmation, and I try to steer people toward examining internalised misogyny and toward informed consent about medical risks.