因引用她從未為質疑而跨性別的研究被封禁
女性 · 已放棄57
這些故事已使用AI進行摘要。
在Reddit上,人們經常在多個評論或貼文中分享他們的經歷。為了使這些資訊更易於訪問,detrans.ai 將所有這些分散的片段收集到一個易於閱讀的摘要和時間線中。所有系統提示詞都在提示詞頁面上註明。
有時AI可能會產生幻覺或陳述不真實的內容。但一般來說,摘要故事是用戶原始評論的準確反映。
摘要
我是一名支持去跨性別的女性,從未跨性別,公開反對我所認為的對質疑自身性別的兒童有害的文化壓力,以及反對壓制跨性別社群的負面結果。我個人從未跨性別,但公開支持去跨性別者,引用有關跨性別後自殺率的研究,並把跨性別社群描述為邪教。我遭到男性的攻擊和虐待,這塑造了我對女性經歷的看法,無論性別表達如何。我因表達批評觀點而被一個社群封禁。現在我認同為女性,並繼續公開主張對跨性別保持謹慎,尤其是對年輕人。
完整故事
I grew up doing and liking many things that were considered "tomboy" activities, but I never questioned my gender — I liked to do what I liked to do and that was that. I've always been a feminine woman, though I describe that as biology rather than anything I chose: I don't wear makeup or anything, I just look like a "girly girl" regardless. I've always felt like that femininity was a curse, because I get harassed and hit on unwantedly by men, and I've been assaulted too. Being a feminine woman didn't spare me from harassment — perhaps the harassment is different, but it's still harassment nonetheless. I think butch women are super sexy and I love them.
I never transitioned myself, but I became an outspoken critic of what I see as a harmful cultural climate around gender. I worry that in today's climate I would have been pushed toward questioning my gender simply because of what is being taught to kids, even though I never questioned it myself. I believe gender "roles" are more rigid now than ever, and that otherwise normal kids are left wondering if something is wrong with them. The first response shouldn't be to question a child's gender — it should be acceptance of what the child enjoys without insistence on complying with gender roles. I think we've gone backwards in letting kids just be kids, and that progress toward accepting kids as they are, without stereotyping "boys'" and "girls'" toys, is being undone. In attempting to address a very small group, we are harming everybody. I don't think it's "woke" to tear apart girls' and boys' ability to express themselves while planting seeds of gender dysmorphia, or to demand lesbians accept transgender men as women and attack them if they don't — I've said those people aren't "woke," they're in a "manosphere coma."
I've engaged with detransitioners directly and supported them publicly. I told one person, "Good for you for speaking out," believing the only way to prevent more young, vulnerable people from making what I consider a mistake is for people to speak up about their experiences. I congratulated another person on stopping hormones, saying they were doing their body and psyche a massive favor. I've been banned from a community for saying that the trans community has an agenda that isn't for the betterment of people or helping them become "their authentic selves" — if it were, they'd accept what's right for each individual. I've described the trans community as having a "weird cult-like mentality" that shuts down negative results and suppresses knowledge of serious downsides.
I knew a friend who had bottom surgery years ago (male-to-female) and later detransitioned, and was extremely despondent — not about his dysmorphia, but about how he was mutilated. He chose to go back to his natal gender. He was so certain he had to have reassignment surgery to be happy, and all it did was ruin his life. That experience deeply shaped my views. I've also cited research, including the Williams Institute/AFSP suicide report, arguing that suicide rates are actually higher post-transition.
I've been harassed online for my views — one person called me a "big cash cow" for the pharma industry, which I found ironic given where hormone treatments come from. I've also been assaulted by men in the past, an experience that informs how I think about women's safety and harassment regardless of presentation. Currently I identify as a woman, detransition-adjacent in the sense that I'm an active critic and supporter of detransitioners, though I have not personally transitioned or detransitioned.