detrans.ai 

Back to studies

دراسة حاصرات بتمويل NIH لا تجد تحسناً في الصحة النفسية على مدى سنتين؛ دون مجموعة ضابطة وبيانات مفقودة 37% عند 24 شهراً

الصحة النفسية والعاطفية للشباب بعد 24 شهراً من الرعاية الطبية المؤكِّدة للجندر التي بدأت بكبح البلوغ

دراسات الأتراب والسجلاتمثبطات البلوغالصحة النفسية والانتحار
Authors
Johanna Olson-Kennedy, Ramon Durazo-Arvizu, Liyuan Wang, Carolyn F. Wong, Diane Chen, Diane Ehrensaft, Marco A. Hidalgo, Yee-Ming Chan, Robert Garofalo, Asa E. Radix, Stephen M. Rosenthal
Journal
medRxiv (preprint)
Year
2025
Source
https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.05.14.25327614

Summary

This NIH-funded study followed 94 children and young teens (average age 11) who started puberty blockers at four large US gender clinics. Over two years, their own reports of depression and emotional wellbeing, and parents' reports of behaviour, did not measurably improve. Average scores were normal from the start. The authors read this as a sign blockers probably prevented a decline, but with no comparison group that claim is untested. More than a third of depression data were missing at two years, about a third started cross-sex hormones during the study, and the results reported differ from those first planned. In 2024 the lead author told The New York Times she had delayed publishing for fear the results would be "weaponized"; they appeared as an unreviewed preprint (early version) in May 2025. It shows no measurable mental health benefit.

Key findings

  • تمت متابعة 94 شاباً وشابة بأعمار 8 إلى 16 (متوسط 11؛ 52% وُلدوا ذكوراً؛ معظمهم في بدايات البلوغ) بدؤوا حاصرات البلوغ في أربع عيادات أمريكية لمدة سنتين.
  • لم تظهر تقاريرهم الخاصة عن الاكتئاب والصحة العاطفية، ولا تقارير الأهل عن المشكلات، أي تغير قابل للقياس على مدى سنتين؛ ولم ينخفض سوى السلوك المخالف للقواعد قليلاً.
  • كان لدى 18% اكتئاب متوسط أو شديد في البداية (16 من 88) و23% عند سنتين (13 من 59).
  • كان لدى 59 فقط من 94 بيانات اكتئاب عند سنتين، لذا فُقد 37%.
  • بدأ 11 الإستروجين أو التستوستيرون خلال السنة الأولى و20 آخرون في الثانية، لذا تناول ثلث المشاركين الهرمونات المغايرة أثناء الدراسة.
  • أبلغ 11 شاباً عن أفكار انتحارية في الأشهر الستة قبل البداية و5 عند سنتين؛ ولم تكن هناك وفيات انتحار.
  • خلص المؤلفون إلى أن الحاصرات «ربما» تمنع تدهور الصحة النفسية، رغم أن الدراسة، لعدم وجود مجموعة مقارنة، لم تستطع اختبار ذلك.
  • توقع تقرير التقدم الصادر عن NIH انخفاض الاكتئاب والقلق وأعراض الصدمة وإيذاء النفس والأفكار الانتحارية، وتحسن صورة الجسد وجودة الحياة؛ ولم تظهر هذه التحسنات.

Abstract

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Medical interventions for youth with gender dysphoria can include the use of gonadotropin releasing hormone analogs (GnRHas) for suppression of endogenous puberty. This analysis aimed to understand the impact of medical intervention initiated with GnRHas on psychological well-being among youth with gender dysphoria over 24 months.

METHODS: Participants were enrolled as part of the Trans Youth Care United States Study. Eligibility criteria for youth included a diagnosis of Gender Dysphoria and pubertal initiation. Youth with precocious puberty or pre-existing osteoporosis were ineligible. Youth reported on depressive symptoms, emotional health and suicidality at baseline, 6, 12, 18 and 24 months after initiation of GnRHas. Parent/caretaker completed the Child Behavior Checklist at baseline, 12 and 24 months after initiation of GnRHas. Latent Growth-Curve Models analyzed trajectories of change over the 24-month period.

RESULTS: Ninety-four youth aged 8-16 years (mean=11.2 y) were predominately Non-Hispanic White (56%), early pubertal (86%) and assigned male at birth (52%). Depression symptoms, emotional health and CBCL constructs did not change significantly over 24 months. At no time points were the means of depression, emotional health or CBCL constructs in a clinically concerning range.

CONCLUSION: Participants initiating medical interventions for gender dysphoria with GnRHas have self- and parent-reported psychological and emotional health comparable with the population of adolescents at large, which remains relatively stable over 24 months. Given that the mental health of youth with gender dysphoria who are older is often poor, it is likely that puberty blockers prevent the deterioration of mental health.

Conclusion

Participants initiating medical interventions for gender dysphoria with GnRHas have self- and parent-reported psychological and emotional health comparable with the population of adolescents at large, which remains relatively stable over 24 months. Given that the mental health of youth with gender dysphoria who are older is often poor, it is likely that puberty blockers prevent the deterioration of mental health. (Full-text conclusion: the average mental health as reported by both the youth and parents remains in a clinically non-significant range over two years.)