Summary
In a short editorial for a nursing education journal, New Zealand mental health nurse Jason Watson asks what nurses should do when it is unclear whether a young person with gender distress can give properly informed consent to medical treatment. He starts from the International Council of Nurses' three principles of informed consent: respecting the patient's right to decide, giving accurate and evidence-based information, and making sure consent is given freely, without pressure. Pointing to the Cass Review, he argues that the evidence for gender-affirming treatment is not strong enough to meet those standards, and he questions how far young patients can consent. His answer is 'watchful waiting': a deliberate period of assessment and observation that avoids treatments with long-term or irreversible effects, and gives nurses time to identify other mental health conditions, neurodevelopmental conditions, psychosocial difficulties and peer or social influences. He presents it as a patient-centred approach while the evidence develops. It is an opinion piece by a clinician who openly favours this approach, not a study, and offers no new data.
Key findings
- Watson se demande si l'attente vigilante devrait être la première réponse clinique lorsqu'il n'est pas clair qu'un jeune en détresse de genre puisse donner un consentement réellement éclairé à un traitement médical.
- Il fonde le consentement éclairé sur le Code de déontologie du Conseil international des infirmières : le respect de l'autonomie, une information exacte et fondée sur des données probantes, et un consentement donné librement, sans contrainte.
- En citant la Cass Review, il soutient que l'« absence de base de données probantes solide » sur les traitements d'affirmation de genre rend difficile la transmission aux patients de l'information exacte que le consentement exige.
- À partir d'une définition du NICE, il décrit l'attente vigilante comme une approche délibérée qui laisse du temps à l'évaluation et à l'observation et évite des traitements inutiles aux effets durables ou irréversibles.
- Ce temps permet aux infirmiers de repérer les troubles de santé mentale et du neurodéveloppement associés, les difficultés psychosociales, ainsi que les influences des pairs ou de l'entourage social.
- Il présente l'attente vigilante comme une approche centrée sur le patient pendant que les données probantes se développent, et comme un sujet auquel les formateurs en soins infirmiers devraient préparer les étudiants.
Abstract
This editorial asks whether a watchful waiting intervention is an appropriate initial clinical response for young people experiencing gender dysphoria when it is uncertain that effective informed consent to medical treatment can be given. It frames informed consent through the three principles of the International Council of Nurses (ICN) Code of Ethics (respect for patient autonomy, the provision of accurate, comprehensive and evidence-based information, and consent given voluntarily and free from coercion) and notes the challenge for nurse educators of preparing student nurses to apply these principles in complex clinical areas. Citing the Cass Review (2024), it points to the lack of a robust evidence base for gender-affirming treatment and questions patients' capacity to give informed consent. It then describes watchful waiting, using a NICE (2019) definition, as a deliberate, evidence-informed approach that allows time for comprehensive assessment and observation while avoiding unnecessary interventions with long-term or irreversible consequences.
Conclusion
A cautious, developmentally informed approach such as watchful waiting may offer a patient-centred framework for young people with gender dysphoria while the evidence base continues to develop. The time it creates allows nurses to identify co-existing conditions and risks, including psychosocial difficulties, co-occurring mental health disorders, neurodevelopmental conditions and peer or social influences, before any long-term or irreversible intervention is considered.